Gastro SER | José Carlos Capel y el fin de la crítica gastronómica

·1 hr·4 clips

Why did a chef refuse to give a customer bread with their dish, and what does that reveal about the end of culinary dictatorship?

1. Gastro SER host Carlos Cano interviews José Carlos Capel, food critic at El País and president of Madrid Fusión, ahead of the Madrid Fusión 2025 congress. 2. José Carlos Capel is described as one of Spain's greatest authorities on gastronomy; he has written 45 books, collaborated with El País for decades, and runs the digital publication Gastroactitud with his wife Julia Pérez. 3. The episode's organizing question is the state of Spanish fine dining and food culture—from the future of tasting menus to the predicted disappearance of the home kitchen by 2050. 4. Capel explains the Madrid Fusión 2025 theme 'the client takes command' as a reaction to years of authoritarian dining: chefs refusing bread, sommeliers narrating the winemaker's father's life story, and cloned tasting menu formats that leave diners exhausted. 5. He predicts tasting menus will not disappear—they have legitimate economic and artistic purposes—but says as a personal diner he finds them 'fairly uninteresting' at present. 6. Capel notes that the current information environment makes it structurally impossible for any new chef to achieve the cultural visibility of Adrià, Arzak, or Berasategui in their prime, citing Disfrutar—ranked number one in the world—as barely known to the Spanish general public. 7. He describes the gastronomic ranking ecosystem as a 'jungle': 50 Best, Michelin, The Best Chefs, and individual influencer lists all contradict each other, leaving comensales 'totally disoriented.' 8. Capel argues that independent food criticism is now 'cornered' and structurally endangered: it requires travel budgets, restaurant bills without obligation, and the willingness to publish uncomfortable opinions rather than acting as a 'grateful stomach.' 9. After 35 years as food critic at El País, Capel confirms he was not replaced—the newspaper simply chose to have no food criticism—which he says reflects the economic and institutional pressures facing serious criticism. 10. He criticizes gastronomy social media as 'continuous hyperbole,' with influencers claiming 'the best patatas bravas' without evidence and copy-pasting rankings from others rather than visiting the restaurants they review. 11. Capel confirms he has not published a book in 15 years, choosing instead to express opinions through shorter articles; he describes a never-written book he considers his missed project: a history of 40 years of Spanish culinary transition from the Basque nouvelle cuisine of 1978 to the present. 12. He endorses Mercadona chairman Juan Roig's prediction that Spanish homes will eliminate kitchens by 2050, noting that buildings with only a microwave are already being constructed, and that 550 million hamburgers were consumed in Spain in 2024. 13. Capel describes traditional Spanish cuisine as 'in free fall' and says it is impossible to fight the global trend toward fast, uncommitted food—though he distinguishes this from the elite gastronomy world, which will survive as a minority luxury. 14. His most uncomfortable restaurant moment: dining at the Hotel Meliá in Tenerife when two excited chefs asked how he enjoyed his meal; he had watched them destroy a premium carabinero prawn from Lanzarote and told them directly, 'You should open a shoe shop, because cooking is not your thing.' 15. Three memorable meals cited: a bouillabaisse in Marseille, fish at La Huertona (a one-Michelin-star grill in Ribadesella, Asturias), and a tortilla de patata with escabeche of lamprey at the Casillas de Betanzos in Galicia, made by two women frying potatoes directly into a perolo of olive oil. 16. Capel asks to leave a question for an upcoming Ferran Adrià interview: 'Why did you never cook meat?' He says Adrià's stated reason—'I don't know how to cook it'—is a joke, since Adrià mastered everything else at El Bulli. 17. The tone is intimate and meandering: two professionals who clearly know each other well, moving between congress preparation, philosophical pessimism about food culture, personal anecdotes, and institutional criticism. 18. The interview includes brief interludes and a handoff to Santi Rivas to discuss Madrid Fusión's Wine Edition program with Artisan Wine Attraction. 19. Spanish-speaking listeners interested in fine dining, gastronomy criticism, food culture trends, and the institutional history of Spanish cuisine will find this episode substantive. 20. Non-Spanish speakers or those seeking a more structured argument will find the conversational format and Spanish-language content a barrier.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Gastro SER