GandM: Turning Points in History · GandM - AI Deep Dives

Second Cold War

·1 hr 28 min·5 clips

Alfred W. McCoy warns a Taiwan embargo could push the U.S. back to the Second Island Chain.

The episode opens by treating second Cold War, Cold War II, and new Cold War as different labels for the same growing tension. It presents the term as one of the most disputed geopolitical ideas of the 21st century. The core frame is a dual rivalry. On one side are the United States and key allies, especially NATO. On the other side is a stronger alignment between Russia and China. Russia is described as the successor state and security inheritor of the Soviet Union's role. The episode then turns to Europe. Mayer and Kowalski are cited as arguing that Europe’s older three-part view of China as partner, competitor, and rival leaves out a security dimension. Their criticism centers on China’s material support for Russia and the link between that support and the war in Ukraine. The show treats that alignment as a major break from the original Cold War, when the Soviet Union and China were split by a bitter ideological break. It then zooms in on the U.S.-China relationship. The Trump era is presented as a moment when the rhetoric escalated sharply. China is described there as an existential challenge to U.S. global leadership. That concern led the CIA to produce a focused assessment of China’s long-term strategy under Xi Jinping. Michael Collins delivered that assessment in July 2018. He called it a quiet kind of Cold War. The point was that China was not aiming for a direct kinetic war or a Soviet-style tank buildup. Instead, it was trying to replace the United States as the leading global power through other means. The episode names those means directly. They include infrastructure investment, especially through the Belt and Road Initiative. They also include diplomatic leverage, influence operations, and technological dominance. State-sponsored IP theft is treated as central to that strategy. From there, the episode asks a practical question. If China seeks replacement rather than confrontation, how do you deter it? The answer given is that deterrence changes when the conflict is economic and digital rather than openly military. The Soviet Union presented a visible military threshold. China operates more in the shadows. That makes the struggle chronic, non-kinetic, and harder to pin down. The episode then brings in Niall Ferguson, writing in January 2020, to deepen that argument about a globally intertwined, high-risk competition. The close returns to the larger warning. If the Cold War is back, the episode asks whether the world is less prepared now than it was before. Arms control treaties, diplomatic safeguards, and crisis controls appear thin or absent. The result is not a clean split into two camps. It is a globally intertwined, high-risk competition where economic fragmentation and military volatility are unfolding at the same time.

As heard by us

A clear look at how Cold War language now fits a wider economic, military, and technological rivalry.

It treats the idea of a second Cold War as something contested but hard to ignore, and that tension gives the piece its strongest edge. The clearest passages connect U.S.-China rivalry with Europe, Russia, and NATO, especially when China’s ties and material support for Russia…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a clear map of a new great-power rivalry?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from GandM: Turning Points in History