Front Row

Review: Wuthering Heights film and Jack Thorne's Lord of the Flies

·42 min·4 clips
Emerald Fennell's Wuthering Heights opens with a sexualised public hanging, while Jack Thorne adapts Lord of the Flies for TV.
Tom Sutcliffe frames the programme around classic novels in new adaptations. He begins with Emerald Fennell's Wuthering Heights. The film's title appears in quotation marks, a choice treated as a signal that it is not presenting itself as a canonical version of Emily Bronte's novel. The discussion then moves to Jack Thorne's new television version of Lord of the Flies. Thorne is introduced as the writer of Netflix's international hit Adolescence, and the new work returns to boys going feral. The panel responds to the performances, especially the gamble of leaning on child actors. The child cast is described as very good. The visual design becomes a livelier point of disagreement because the lush jungle island is both beautiful and, for one view, too insistently foregrounded. Long montages are compared to sequences of National Geographic photos. Early 20th century British music is noted alongside those images. The discussion links this handling of landscape with Walkabout's sinister sense of nature. Another view is that the visual passages stretch out the episodes and leave the storytelling less taut than it could be. Sutcliffe asks whether the programme would suit a young child. A contributor says it felt more like viewing for adults than something to watch with children, especially from the perspective of a parent who last knew the book as a child. The conversation also reaches the scene of the pig hunt. The programme then turns from screen adaptation to the Southbank Centre's Grade 2 listing. Sutcliffe asks Ellis and Merritt whether they like brutalist buildings or have learned to love them. One response sees brutalism as part of the landscape without making it a personal taste, while another accepts the buildings but would not want to live in one. James Meek's novel Your Life Without Me is reviewed in relation to the competing claims of the old and the new in architecture and in life. Front Row moves between film, television, architecture, and fiction while keeping its focus on how works are remade and received.

As heard by us

A measured adaptation debate weighs hypnotic Lord of the Flies imagery against storytelling that could be tighter.

Front Row sets recent adaptations against the weight of the works behind them, moving from Emerald Fennell's Wuthering Heights to Jack Thorne's television Lord of the Flies before opening out to the Southbank Centre's Grade 2 listing and James Meek's Your Life Without Me.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want classic novels tested on screen, from Emerald Fennell's Wuthering Heights to Jack Thorne's boys going feral.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on