Friends with Fantasy Benefits | Baseball

FWFB | Baseball - Episode 861 (w/Eric Samulski of RotoWorld)

·1 hr 3 min·5 clips
Justin Mason and Dave McDonald reunite after listener DMs begged for lineup help, sparking a bull session on fantasy baseball's toughest injuries.
The host introduces the Friends of Fancy Benefits Baseball Podcast and welcomes Dave McDonald. The discussion quickly settles on injured pitchers and the roster choices that come with them. Dustin May has looked good. Shane McClanahan has not created the same confidence, and the speakers sort through that gap with probability rather than wishful thinking. One speaker says the safer move can be skipping the whole group unless one player drops to an unusually friendly draft point. That approach accepts missing one pitcher to be right on the other eight. The conversation then puts opportunity cost in the spotlight, where managers do not always leave enough room for it. A player on the injured list still occupies a roster spot while other possible breakouts stay available. Spencer Strider becomes the clean example. His absence creates a dead spot that limits a manager's ability to bid on emerging options. George Kirby and Sean Minaya come up as personal examples of that miss. Minaya was held in two leagues after going around pick 220, or possibly a little higher. That draft slot could have gone to Drew Rasmussen, Lizardo, Waka, Bubic, or other pitchers helping in the first couple months. The comparison makes the lost early-season production feel less theoretical. The speaker also revisits the assumption that an oblique injury would keep Minaya out for only two or three weeks. The expected return window did not actually make the stash cheap. The same issue connects to Kirby, whose early returns have disappointed. Their own decisions become part of the analysis, not a separate confession. The exchange stays trained on draft price, roster flexibility, and when the help actually arrives.

As heard by us

A clear, probability-minded review of the roster cost behind sidelined pitcher stashes.

Fantasy baseball's pitcher-stash debate is treated here as a probability problem with a real roster bill attached. Dustin May, Shane McClanahan, Spencer Strider, George Kirby, and Sean Minaya are weighed against the draft picks, bench spots, and in-season bids required to keep…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You are weighing an injured pitcher stash against the roster spot and breakout arm you could chase today.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on