Forgotten: Wisconsin Cold Cases Podcast · Kassandra Sepeda/WSAW

Forgotten: Unidentified Remains - The Waiting Game

·17 min·1 clip
A Wisconsin homeowner used a human skull as a Halloween prop for three years before discovering it was real.
Sean White opens by asking whether investigators should disturb the ground at all. He frames the work as slow, exacting, and often just a matter of waiting. The episode focuses on two unidentified remains in Oneida County, Jane Doe 1947 and Jane Doe 2021. One was found in the woods off Highway 51 and County Highway L, and the other was located off an easement road off Sheep Branch Road in the town of Cajun. White makes clear that these are only two cases in a much larger pile. Medical Examiner Crystal Schaub says her office now oversees five unidentified cases in Oneida and Vilas Counties, so the work has to be prioritized. Some remains are simply too old for easy answers, especially when DNA may no longer be available. Even so, the show points to John Doe 1980, solved last December, as proof that older cases can still move. The 1947 Doe becomes the main historical thread. A 1947 newspaper article says a woman was buried in a shallow grave off old Highway 51. Autopsy records later confirmed strangulation from bone fragments found in her throat. Schaub and the reporting use those records to ask whether kidnapping was part of the crime. That is why the FBI is assisting. The case file also preserves small descriptive details. White runs through her broad nose, her brownish hair turning gray, and her small feet and ankles, noted at size eight and a quarter. He notes that she was wearing silk or similar pants, a large corset, and a gold wedding band on her left ring finger. That ring sharpens the question of why no one came forward. White says he looked through missing-person records before 1947 and found almost nothing. The episode closes with the same hope that drives the series: coverage, DNA work, and genealogy can still return a name to these remains. Until they are identified, they remain part of the 13 cases Schaub oversees, and the episode ends with a call for information and DNA help.

As heard by us

A patient cold-case report that treats unidentified remains as people first and mysteries second.

The episode takes on the hard edge of unidentified-remains work: partial records, difficult evidence, and the long effort to give two Jane Does a name.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a careful Jane Doe case built around patience, evidence, and place, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on