Forgotten: Wisconsin Cold Cases Podcast · Kassandra Sepeda/WSAW

Forgotten: Cassandra Ayon - Justicia Inconclusa

·18 min·1 clip
The host makes a direct plea: 'Maybe someone listening right now knows something - her son deserves closure, her family deserves closure.'
Cassandra Aon was last seen on October 3, 2020, and after that she was never heard from again. Her disappearance is tied to a homicide case, and by 2022 the person responsible for her death was behind bars. Even so, the case is still open. Police believe he may have had accomplices. That possibility shapes the whole episode. It does not treat the arrest as the end of the story. It keeps coming back to the question of who else may know what happened. The episode opens by noting that Cassandra and the person responsible are members of the Hispanic and Spanish-speaking community, and that is part of why it is being released in both English and Spanish. Paz Gonzalez hosts the episode. Melissa Perez and Juan Toro revoice the interviews. The format is meant to make the story easier to reach and, hopefully, bring in the right person with critical information. It moves from the basic facts of the disappearance into the police response. Detective Kerry Kern describes how Cassandra's mother and stepfather reported her missing. He explains that the Clark County Sheriff's Office led the investigation with help from state criminal investigators, the Department of Justice, and Marathon County. The episode makes clear that the early signs pointed to trouble rather than a voluntary disappearance. Cassandra had an active social life, friends and family who loved her, a child, and a job she really enjoyed. The people around her did not think she would just walk away. The story then turns to the night before she was reported missing. Police interviewed the last people known to be with her and retraced the routes she may have taken. They did not find signs of a crash on the roads they checked. Friends said she seemed frightened that night. They described her turning off lights and checking windows. She also said her ex-boyfriend Jesus had followed her to work. Amanda recalls that Cassandra had already told her she was afraid of Jesus. She says Cassandra believed he had threatened to make her disappear and that no one would find her. The episode closes by naming Cassandra's description, her vehicle, and the clothing she was last seen wearing. It also gives contact information for investigators and for domestic violence support. The point is not just to tell the story, but to keep it open long enough for someone with information to help bring the case to a close.

As heard by us

A cold case that stays open because the hardest questions are still unanswered.

This episode follows the disappearance of a 27-year-old woman from Clark County and keeps pushing past the arrest to ask what still is not known.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a case that stayed open after an arrest.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on