First Date Follow Up - The Jubal Show · The Jubal Show

He Thought He Was Hilarious… She Thought He Was a Menace 😳🎨🌮

·12 min·1 clip
Naomi explains how Caleb's pottery prank got them banned from the shop, shocking everyone.
Caleb says he has not heard from Naomi for about a week. He says he has tried to reach out, but not too much. The date itself happened at a DIY pottery place. He thought it went well. They joked around and teased each other. Caleb says he got a little too into the moment. He describes doing a ghosting move from behind her while they were at the pottery wheel. The show reacts with surprise at how bold that was. Naomi is brought on the phone after the setup. She says Caleb is the one she has been ghosting. She says the date was fun, but one incident ruined it for her. That incident involved hot sauce. She says she could not breathe. She says it was horrible and embarrassing because people were staring. She says the situation got so bad that a waiter brought her milk and honey. While she was struggling, Caleb was still joking. He made a spicy-relationship joke that did not help. Naomi says the whole thing made him feel less charming and more like a menace. Caleb hears all of this while still on the line. He tries to respond as Naomi keeps pressing her point. The call turns into a live argument about whether he was funny, reckless, or both. The show lets the discomfort play out instead of smoothing it over. Naomi’s reaction gives the segment its edge. Caleb’s confidence keeps getting undercut by the consequences of his own joke. The result is a fast, reactive dating story built on embarrassment, timing, and bad judgment. It ends with the sense that one person's flirtation is another person's disaster.

As heard by us

A pottery date turns awkward once hot sauce and a live call collide.

Caleb's first-date follow-up lands as a tidy little spiral of awkward radio energy: he and Naomi went to a DIY pottery place, traded jokes, and then the hot-sauce moment pushed the night into real embarrassment for her.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A DIY pottery first date goes from teasing to a live ghosting callout, with hot sauce and embarrassment doing most of the damage.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on