Fireside Giants - A New York Giants Podcast · Empire Sports Media, HMA

The Giants NEED to Hire John Harbaugh! | Why He’s the Undisputed Top Option

·37 min·3 clips

The Giants must block John Harbaugh from leaving until he signs, making him their undisputed top coaching option.

Hosts Anthony Rivardo and Alex Wilson of the Fireside Giants podcast react to the sudden availability of former Baltimore Ravens head coach John Harbaugh. They argue Harbaugh is the undisputed top candidate for the New York Giants' vacant head coaching position and must be aggressively pursued. The hosts believe his proven track record and leadership are exactly what the dysfunctional Giants franchise needs to rebuild. The episode details Harbaugh's resume, including his 180 career wins and an NFL record for most playoff road victories. They contrast his three losing seasons in 18 years with the Giants' recent struggles under Brian Daboll. Rivardo emphasizes Harbaugh's identity as a "program builder" who can instill a new culture and discipline, citing player requests from locker room cleanouts. They compare his potential hiring to Jim Harbaugh's turnaround of the Los Angeles Chargers and Andy Reid's success after moving from Philadelphia to Kansas City. A significant portion discusses Harbaugh's extensive coaching tree, which includes developed or hired coordinators like Mike Macdonald, Rex Ryan, Chuck Pagano, and Vic Fangio. The hosts highlight his ability to attract elite assistants, such as Gary Kubiak for the Ravens' Super Bowl run. They explore potential coordinator hires for the Giants, specifically debating the merits of offensive coordinator Todd Monken, noting his aggressive, spacing-based system transformed Lamar Jackson. They also mention Davis Webb as a promising offensive coordinator candidate. The hosts acknowledge potential drawbacks, including Harbaugh's reported excessive loyalty that led to retaining underperiring coordinator Zach Orr in Baltimore. They also discuss his "CEO" style, which relies heavily on coordinator hires and doesn't involve play-calling, and note some criticism of his teams as playoff underachievers. Rivardo counters that Harbaugh would likely seek experienced, elite coordinators for a Giants rebuild, similar to Kevin Stefanski hiring Jim Schwartz in Cleveland. The tone is passionately opinionated and conversational, blending fan excitement with analytical depth about coaching philosophy and team construction. The style is a collaborative debate, with both hosts building on each other's points while playing devil's advocate to provide balance. This episode is perfect for New York Giants fans deeply invested in the head coaching search who want a fervent, detailed argument for a veteran hire. Listeners preferring objective analysis or discussions focused on younger, schematic-minded candidates might find the unwavering advocacy less appealing.

As heard by us

A strong Giants case for Harbaugh, with a clear note of caution about his coaching style.

The Giants discussion settles on John Harbaugh as the leading candidate after his firing opened the search. Anthony Rivardo and Alex Wilson do more than praise the idea; they make a case built on staff building, a collaborative fit with Joe Shane, and the appeal of a CEO-style…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want the Giants case for John Harbaugh, argued like it actually matters?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Fireside Giants - A New York Giants Podcast