Fireside Giants - A New York Giants Podcast · Empire Sports Media, HMA

Joe Shoen Could "Adjust His Role" to land John Harbaugh | Giants Rumors

·30 min·2 clips

Joe Shane could adjust his role and title to land John Harbaugh as the Giants' next head coach.

This episode analyzes the rumor that Giants GM Joe Schoen might alter his duties to facilitate hiring head coach candidate John Harbaugh. Hosts Anthony and Alex, passionate Giants analysts, dissect this potential power shift. They reference a report from Ian O'Connor of The Athletic stating Schoen is "relentlessly recruiting" Harbaugh. O'Connor reported that Schoen is aware Harbaugh wants roster control and is willing to adjust his role to secure him. The hosts note Schoen's record is 13-38 over three years, yet ownership has kept him. They argue hiring Harbaugh, whose worst season since 2016 was 8-9, would immediately raise the team's floor. Harbaugh's potential $20 million salary and demand for a culture overhaul are discussed as worthwhile costs. The hosts cite player Darius Slayton's public desire for a "Tom Coughlin-esque" leader, which O'Connor compared to a "gentler" Harbaugh. A surprising insight is that Schoen's collaboration on past decisions, like trading up for QB Jaden Daniels for former coach Brian Daboll, might actually attract Harbaugh. They propose Schoen could transition into a supportive, research-focused role, learning from Harbaugh's experience. The counterpoint is raised that Harbaugh might still prefer his own GM, but the hosts believe the current pursuit suggests a workable partnership. Anthony revises his critical view of Schoen, respecting this potential sacrifice of power for the team's benefit. They contrast the Giants' situation with other suitors like the Falcons, Titans, and Dolphins, arguing the presence of quarterback Jaden Daniels makes New York the most attractive job. The tone is conversational, enthusiastic, and deeply opinionated, blending reported rumors with fan-centric analysis. This episode is ideal for Giants fans obsessed with front-office politics and coaching search drama. Listeners seeking neutral, league-wide analysis or who are tired of speculative rumors might want to skip it.

As heard by us

A Giants coaching story that makes roster control the main question.

The piece keeps the Giants' coaching search on a plain, practical question: what happens to Joe Shane if John Harbaugh gets the job? It says Shane is safe for now, Harbaugh is set to interview this week, and Harbaugh may want real say over roster construction, possibly with his…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want the Giants' coaching search broken down like a front-office power play?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Fireside Giants - A New York Giants Podcast