Financial Survival Network

Debt Crisis: Too Much Revenue? - John Tamny #6336

·23 min·2 clips
John Tamny argues the US has massive debt because government revenue is too high, not because spending is out of control.
Kerry Lutz opens with the claim that debt exists because revenue is abundant. John Tamney does not wave that away. He argues that any individual, business, or government expected to keep taking in money can borrow. Credit follows the income stream. Tamney says the public keeps blaming spending or under-taxation, and he calls that diagnosis dangerous. Lutz tests the idea against countries such as Haiti and Russia, where low debt cannot simply be credited to classical-liberal politicians choosing restraint. The familiar deficit frame starts to wobble. Tamney's point is that governments borrow when lenders believe future revenue can support the borrowing. The discussion carries a 15-year echo as Lutz remembers Tamney appearing when the channel had three viewers, two of them related to him and the third being Lutz himself. Tamney is identified as president of Parkview Institute and editor of Real Clear Markets. His latest book, The Deficit Delusion, fits the same argument about public misconceptions. Then the market numbers sharpen the conversation, moving it from borrowing theory to a warning about what investors are choosing to buy. Lutz points to gold over 4000 an ounce and silver breaking 50, while the discussion corrects a mistaken reference to 1990 by landing on 1980 for the Hunt brothers debacle. Tamney treats those prices as a crisis already here. People buying gold and silver, he says, are buying wealth that already exists as protection against a weakening dollar. That pulls money into inflation hedges while stock and bond income streams represent future wealth creation. Lutz frames it as a loss of confidence in the system and in the future. Tamney brings artificial intelligence into the same worry, asking how much more progress might have happened without persistent dollar devaluation during the 21st century. The argument keeps returning to what currency weakness says about economic confidence. The close returns to books, including The World According to Martin Armstrong, before Lutz signs off with the Financial Survival Network's promise to be a solution to today's trying times.

As heard by us

Tamney's revenue-first debt argument gains urgency as he reads gold and silver buying as a sign of a crisis already underway.

This single-episode review follows John Tamney's revenue-first view of debt: people, businesses and governments borrow because current and expected income makes borrowing possible.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want to hear an upside-down deficit argument: that America's debt problem starts with too much expected revenue?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on