Fantasy Simpletons - Fantasy Football Show · Fantasy Football

NFL Trade Deadline REACTION: Fantasy Football Winners & Losers (2025)

·28 min·2 clips

The Jets trade Sauce Gardner for two first-round picks, signaling a complete defensive rebuild and fantasy chaos.

This episode of Fantasy Simpletons reacts to the flurry of moves made at the NFL trade deadline. Hosts Jake and his co-host provide immediate fantasy football analysis as the deadline passes. They begin by discussing wide receiver Jacoby Myers' trade from the Las Vegas Raiders to the Jacksonville Jaguars. The hosts analyze the Jaguars' now "stacked" receiver group with Brian Thomas Jr. and the returning Travis Hunter. They speculate this move could make Trey Tucker the Raiders' top wide receiver for the remainder of the season. The show covers the blockbuster trades of cornerback Sauce Gardner to the Indianapolis Colts and defensive lineman Quinnen Williams to the Dallas Cowboys, noting the New York Jets received three total first-round picks. They mention receiver Adonai Mitchell was included in the Gardner trade and is now on the Jets. The hosts express surprise that the Seattle Seahawks, a team they support, acquired receiver Rashid Shaheed from the New Orleans Saints for a fourth and fifth-round pick. They debate Shaheed's fantasy value amidst Seattle's crowded receiver room featuring Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Tyler Lockett, and emerging player Torrey Horton. The conversation touches on the Carolina Panthers releasing quarterback Hendon Hooker and the Miami Dolphins' reportedly high asking price for receiver Jaylen Waddle. They note running back Breece Hall's trade request and the Jets' alleged asking price of a third-round pick. In a waiver wire aside, they highlight Minnesota Vikings quarterback Sam Darnold as a potential weekly starter, especially in Superflex leagues. A non-fantasy trade discussed is the Saints sending offensive lineman Trevor Penning to the Los Angeles Chargers. A surprising claim is that the New England Patriots did not want to re-acquire Jacoby Myers, their former player. They find it "unbelievable" that star defenders were traded while Breece Hall, who requested a move, remained with the Jets. The hosts are intrigued by the potential long-term implications of the Myers trade, wondering if it could lead to a future Brian Thomas Jr. trade. They are excited but uncertain about Rashid Shaheed's immediate fantasy impact in Seattle's complex offense. The show briefly mentions a non-football story about Tom Brady cloning his pet dog, calling it a "definition of crazy rich" action. The tone is highly conversational, excited, and informal, mirroring two friends reacting to breaking sports news in real time. The style blends instant reaction with speculative fantasy analysis, often referencing their personal team fandom. Fantasy football managers seeking immediate deadline reaction and speculative waiver wire advice would enjoy this fast-paced episode. Listeners preferring polished, research-driven analysis or those uninterested in the hosts' personal team biases might want to skip it.

As heard by us

Fast, loose deadline reactions with clear fantasy fallout.

The episode treats the NFL trade deadline as live drama, with two hosts reacting as the news lands and keeping the pace brisk throughout. Its sharpest stretch comes when the conversation pivots from surprise to fantasy impact, especially around Jacoby Myers, Rashid Shaheed, and…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Need instant fantasy fallout from a wild NFL trade deadline?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Fantasy Simpletons - Fantasy Football Show