Fantasy Simpletons - Fantasy Football Show · Fantasy Football

Fantasy Football Week 9 MUST Start & Sit Guide (2025) 🎃 Halloween Special

·1 hr 9 min·5 clips

The Colts' offense is making NFL history with a balance not seen since the 2007 Patriots.

This Halloween special episode of the Fantasy Simpletons Show features hosts Kyle and Jake Fridland providing Week 9 start and sit advice. The brothers analyze key matchups and waiver wire opportunities, focusing on returning players and injury impacts. They discuss the fantasy implications of several quarterback situations and running back committees. Lamar Jackson's likely return for the Ravens-Dolphins game is a major focus, with Derrick Henry and Zay Flowers highlighted as starts. The hosts express caution about starting Tua Tagovailoa despite a recent big game, citing inconsistency. They identify Keaton Mitchell as a Ravens running back to monitor due to increasing involvement. D'Andre Swift is a must-start against the Bengals, while concerns are raised about Caleb Williams' recent fantasy performance resembling his rookie struggles. Jamar Chase is viewed as a weekly top-five receiver due to an immense target share with Joe Flacco, whom the hosts speculate might be better for Chase's fantasy value than Joe Burrow. The Vikings' offensive output against the Lions is considered dependent on J.J. McCarthy's return from injury, making Justin Jefferson, Jordan Addison, and Jordan Mason risky plays. For the Panthers, Rico Dowdle is seen as gaining favor over Chuba Hubbard based on coach comments, though both remain flex options. Tucker Kraft is a must-start tight end for the Packers, with his athleticism and connection with Jordan Love emphasized. The hosts debate starting C.J. Stroud against a strong Broncos secondary, leaning toward sitting him. They are optimistic about Drake Maye's consistency for the Patriots but losing faith in Kirk Cousins and the Falcons' pass-catchers. Jonathan Taylor's historic season and the Colts' record-setting offense are discussed, with Taylor, Daniel Jones, and Michael Pittman all recommended starts. The Chargers' crowded receiver room creates weekly uncertainty, with Quentin Johnston's recent goose egg noted as a concern. Trade deadline speculation includes Titans tight end Chigoziem Okonkwo and Saints receiver Rashid Shaheed as potential candidates to be moved. The tone is casual and brotherly, with humorous Halloween-themed banter interspersed throughout the analysis. Fantasy managers seeking specific start/sit advice for Week 9 lineups will find this episode useful, while those looking for deep statistical analysis or narrative storytelling might want to skip it.

As heard by us

A Halloween Week 9 fantasy chat built around starts, sits, flexes, sleepers, and waiver-wire adds.

This Halloween episode stays centered on starts, sits, flexes, sleepers, and waiver-wire adds. Kyle and Jake Fridland bring the kind of brotherly back-and-forth that fits the show well, and the talk keeps coming back to lineup choices, injury fallout, and which names look ready…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Need Week 9 help while injuries turn your roster into a Halloween costume party?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Fantasy Simpletons - Fantasy Football Show