Fantasy Football Daily · Fantasy Football, Fantasy Points, NFL, Theo Gremminger

2026 NFL Draft Rookie Player Comparisons | The Next Jahmyr Gibbs? 👀

·1 hr 5 min·2 clips
Brett Whitefield calls Jeremiah Love 'the thicker Jahmyr Gibbs' after Love ran the same 40 time as Gibbs.
1. Fantasy Points' 2026 NFL Draft Podcast uses a March episode to match top rookie prospects with current and retired NFL players, framed around the question 'The Next Jahmyr Gibbs?'. 2. Theo Grimminger, who says he did player comps for a couple of years at a previous job, co-hosts with Brett Whitefield, who is releasing his first prospect guide covering QBs, RBs, WRs and TEs. 3. Whitefield says he avoids ceiling-floor comps and prefers play-style comparisons, which sets up their disagreements over players like Makai Lemon and Jordan Tyson. 4. Whitefield calls Jeremiah Love 'the thicker Jahmyr Gibbs' and notes that Love ran the same 40 time as Gibbs, while Grimminger says none of the landing spots mentioned (Titans at four, Saints at eight, Chiefs at nine) would concern him. 5. On Fernando Mendoza, Grimminger offers Tony Romo, Whitefield picks Joe Burrow over Jared Goff, and Grimminger points to parallel trajectories of transfer, national title and Indiana receivers Elijah Sarratt and Omar Cooper. 6. Grimminger compares Makai Lemon to Amon-Ra St. Brown and Chris Godwin, Whitefield jokes about Olamide Zaccheaus, and then both settle on Golden Tate, who had four straight 90-plus catch seasons. 7. For Carnell Tate, Grimminger pairs him with George Pickens, Whitefield mixes A.J. Green, Chris Olave and Devonta Smith, and Whitefield notes Tate's 194-pound frame and 'no drops' hands. 8. Whitefield describes Jordan Tyson as 'more of a TikTok route runner' who is by far the rawest first-round receiver, while Grimminger defends the Stefon Diggs comp and a 125 to 150 target range. 9. The pair also compare KC Concepcion to Brandon Aiyuk, Omar Cooper Jr. to Rashee Rice and DJ Moore, Chris Brazel to Christian Watson, Denzel Boston to Tee Higgins and Puka Nacua, and Skylar Bell to Jayden Reed. 10. Dynasty and best ball managers following the 2026 draft class will get the most from it.
Listen to the show on