Fan Critical: A TV and Film Podcast · Fan Critical

The Last Of Us Episode 1 - Hot Take

January 16, 2023·27 min·2 clips
Gareth was so on edge during the outbreak that his wife's call about honey soy crisps felt like a horror moment.
The Cast of Us starts the way a fan panel should start, with relief and a bit of ceremony. The hosts treat the HBO series premiere like Outbreak Day, which is exactly the level of commitment the subject calls for. A whisky bottle comes out early, and the banter keeps the tone loose and matey. They spend the first stretch greeting each other, joking about the small studio, and settling in. From there they jump to the episode's 1960s virus-explanation scene. The invented bit gets a warm response, especially the presenter and the little pen-clicking fidget detail. It is not just a joke to them. They think it explains the virus in a way that feels sly and slightly off-kilter. The biggest chunk of the discussion goes to the opening outbreak sequence. They call it the part they had been waiting so long to see visualized. What they like most is that the TV episode stretches the early material instead of rushing through it. Sarah gets more room to breathe, and that extra time matters to them. The school day, the visit to another house, and the slow build all get folded into the same long tension ramp. That slower climb is part of why the sequence lands so hard. Once the chaos starts, they feel the episode earns it. They are especially pleased that the show keeps the back-of-the-car angle from the game. That viewpoint makes the collapse feel like something the audience is trapped inside rather than just watching. They also praise Joel and Tommy's dialogue. For them, those lines help ground the spectacle in real family panic. The conversation keeps circling back to how the series balances fidelity and expansion. It is not a slavish copy. It is the same material, given more room for Sarah and more dread for the audience. Nana gets her own section of the conversation, and not because she is comforting. The hosts find her properly terrifying. The chair moment behind the characters gets called out as the creepiest beat in the episode. That scare turns into a quick Ari Aster comparison. The horror framing suits the way they are watching the premiere. They move fast, argue a little, and keep landing on craft points instead of empty hype. The whole review stays brisk and a little unruly. Banter, corrections, and sudden sidetracks are part of the method. Even the closing stretch stays characterful. They drift into supply-run jokes, rations, and the running gag about John eating everything. Then the episode shuts down with the familiar call to endure and survive.

As heard by us

A lively, game aware premiere chat with enough looseness to keep it moving.

The Cast of Us frames the HBO premiere as a real event, and that energy suits the episode. The hosts do their best work when they unpack Sarah's long day, the back-of-the-car angle carried over from the game, and the Joel and Tommy exchanges that keep the collapse feeling…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a game-vs-TV breakdown of The Last of Us HBO premiere.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on