Evolving Hockey Podcast · Evolving Hockey Staff

Episode 148: Sports Tier List Discussion

June 11, 2025·1 hr 8 min·4 clips
Three or four GMs would reportedly do whatever it takes to get Sam Bennett this summer.
Sean, Josh, and Luke open the show by admitting the start is a bit of a mess. The microphone gets treated like it might be haunted, and everyone has a theory about what went wrong, even if none of them are very helpful. That gives the first stretch its tone. From there, the conversation drifts toward a sports tier-list discussion, but it never settles into anything neat. The room keeps interrupting itself. A point starts, gets checked, gets revised, then gets folded into another joke. Everyone seems fine with that, so the detours become the real shape of the episode. Tage Thompson becomes one of the bigger recurring subjects, though never in a serious, straight-faced way. The group veers into exaggerated theories about him being replaced, upgraded, or otherwise turned into a different kind of player. That opens the door to old pop-culture bits, including The Jersey and the kind of athlete-swap fantasy that only really works in a hockey room with too much time and not enough restraint. The same idea keeps circling back: some players show up looking like one thing and end up becoming something else entirely. The episode also keeps coming back to the idea that certain players seem to have been touched by some invisible force that made them way better than expected. That is where the Spider-Man talk lands, with the group joking about a good shooter somehow biting someone into greatness. The comparison is absurd, but it fits how they talk about breakout players: part model, part memory, part nonsense, and all of it blended together. There is still a clear sense of the wider hockey calendar in the room. The panel notes that the Cup situation may still be going, and that the next recording might land before it is fully settled. That uncertainty becomes part of the episode's texture instead of something to fix. The conversation keeps moving, then backing up, then moving again, as if the show is happening inside a season that refuses to pause for a clean take. Even when the group shifts to scheduling or timing, they do it in the same loose, recursive style. One person starts to frame the next week, another jumps in to correct the timing, and the whole thing becomes a reminder that the show is built from conversation rather than script. The tier-list discussion is less a polished ranking exercise than a way for the group to do what they always do: argue, remember, drift, and eventually land somewhere roughly meaningful after several turns. The episode closes with a promise to come back next week and keep improvising around whatever hockey reality looks like then. It might be the Cup, it might be free agency, it might be another tier list, and the show seems perfectly content not to know yet. That uncertainty is not treated like a gimmick. It is just how they talk. The key idea is that hockey analysis here comes wrapped in banter, memory, and a willingness to wander until the point finally shows up.

As heard by us

A tier-list chat that keeps drifting into better jokes than structure.

The episode starts in technical trouble and settles into loose, amused hockey banter between Sean, Josh, and Luke. The tier-list hook is there, but the real pull is the way the conversation keeps veering into player mythology, especially the long running joke around Tage…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want hockey talk that happily drifts off course.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on