Everyday Driver Car Debate · Everyday Driver

994: Ruining The Cayman, The Next Horse, Made-Up Theater

May 6, 2025·1 hr 1 min·5 clips
Paul declares an all-wheel drive Cayman 'does not need to exist in any powertrain at any time'.
The opening is about podcast 994, and Paul and Todd talk through the studio changes, the move toward video, and the plan to mark the 1,000th episode at Koda. The gathering at the top of Koda Tower will be limited, and they say they will sell tickets because only about 40 people can be up there. Then it shifts to listener mail. David in North Carolina writes back after the Civic recommendation, says it led him to a 2018 Jaguar XFS Sportbrake, and gives the practical details: 17,000 miles, one owner, full maintenance records, 14 months of factory warranty left, and an extended warranty from CarMax. That's a wagon. The hosts lean into how rare it is, with a joke that there are fewer than 250 in the country and a quick comparison to buying an Irish horse. The horse bit takes over for a minute. They riff on what would even make a horse Irish, whether you would know it by looking, and how little the category tells you on its own. The real question comes back fast. David is a widower with two tall and still-growing sons, one of them 6'4", so the back seat matters more than the badge. The LS500 comes up next. He had looked at it already, but the rear seat did not give him the headroom he hoped for. The Volvo list stays in play. The XC90, V90, and V60 all kept making sense because they had the space he wanted and were serious contenders right up until the Jaguar. The Kia Stinger GT gets a fair hearing too. It was not rejected because it was bad; it just lost out to other cars that fit the family brief better. The show keeps tightening the logic. Paul and Todd restate the facts, push back on the emotional excuses, and keep testing which compromises are real and which ones are just enthusiast rationalization. Sponsor reads and event talk still show up. Even so, the segment keeps coming back to the same point: the right car has to work for the people who actually sit in it, not just the person who wants to brag about finding it.

As heard by us

A rare Jaguar wagon kicks off a practical, slightly wandering car debate.

Episode 994 follows a listener update with a practical turn: a Civic recommendation leads to a 2018 Jaguar XFS Sportbrake, a wagon said to be one of fewer than 250 in the country.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a practical, funny car-debate answer about a rare wagon choice, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on