Chiveman and a mountain of margarine

November 21, 2025·27 min·1 clip

A Reddit commenter named Autumn spent hours piecing together a year-long trail of margarine posts — including a Glock purchase — and asked: what the f*** is going on?

Timid knife skills open the door. The hosts start with a kitchen check-in, talking cautious chopping and rustic cooking before the conversation wanders into Chive Challenge lore. It gets odd quickly. A Redditor tags Endless Thread on a post that reached Best Of, pointing them toward a story that feels too specific to ignore. They follow it. The post is from Unethical LifeProTips, where someone asks how to move 13 2,000-pound pallets of margarine sideways and into a six-foot hole. Quietly, somehow. The margarine cannot melt, change shape, or be harmed, which makes every line sound worse. Emery reads along. The username, Occasionally Vertical, turns into its own joke, since the whole plan involves moving a massive pile downward into the ground. Then the hosts start side-eyeing the premise. One calls it AI engagement bait. The other notices that commenters are still circling the obvious: what is this, where is it happening, and is any of it legal? Nobody feels better after that. The poster keeps giving the same basic energy: nothing strange here, just extra margarine lying around. That does not help. The fun is in letting the logistics hang there until the whole thing feels like a food problem nobody should have. A news link shows up near the edge of the excerpt, hinting that the margarine mystery may have another root. Keep the ads out, and what remains is Endless Thread in its comfort zone: one ordinary object, one deeply suspicious Reddit plea, and hosts enjoying the moment curiosity beats sense.

As heard by us

A funny, oddly gripping Reddit mystery about chives, kitchen banter, and a suspicious mountain of margarine.

Endless Thread starts with a loose knife-skills exchange, then follows Reddit straight into a gloriously strange kitchen-adjacent mystery: the Chive Challenge, the Kitchen Confidential subreddit, and a desperate plea about moving 13 pallets of margarine into a six-foot hole…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You are about to become the person who cannot stop talking about a Reddit margarine mystery.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Endless Thread