Email Marketing Experiments 🧪: Email Marketing Strategies for Business Owners, Service Providers & Freelancers · Dr. Ayebanoa Sapphire Benwari

#42: Why I'm Allergic to Email Marketing with Michelle Wintersteen

·45 min·3 clips
Michelle says her list has about 3,000 people she built with freebies and then “never nurtured that list.”
1. Email Marketing Experiments 🧪 features Dr. Safaya and Michelle Wintersteen on why Michelle says she is “allergic to email marketing.” 2. Safaya introduces Michelle as the founder and creative director of NKW Creative Co. in San Diego and the host of Kiss My Aesthetics. 3. The episode asks how a branding studio owner with a 3,000-person list can turn email from a source of aversion into a useful marketing channel. 4. Michelle says she started her business as a junior in college at age 20 and began charging $15 an hour for graphic design. 5. She says her parents told her to “charge more than you would babysitting,” after she had been making $12 an hour as a nanny. 6. Michelle credits YouTube, Google, and social media for helping her learn design skills without formal work experience. 7. She says she became a digital nomad for a few years and built a global client base while living in countries all over the world. 8. Michelle says January 2020 pushed her to hire team members because she had more work than she could do alone and was getting burnt out. 9. She says NKW Creative Co. now handles branding, ongoing creative direction, print, digital, merchandise, and social presence. 10. Michelle defines “brag worthy” as word-of-mouth growth for businesses that help people and communities. 11. Michelle says her podcast began as an Instagram Live show called Design Live that she used to network with designers. 12. She says a friend told her the show should become a podcast because Instagram Live disappears after the session ends. 13. Michelle says the podcast became a way to improve her public speaking and to combine topics from her different work worlds. 14. She says she brings former clients onto the show as case studies and calls those episodes an “hour long testimonial” for her services. 15. Michelle says one example is Lilypar, a golf apparel company in La Jolla, which she uses as a referral marketing example for prospective clients. 16. Michelle says she built her email list at age 22, 23, and 24 by giving away freebies after listening to Jenna Kutcher. 17. She says she never nurtured that list and now thinks of it as a stadium full of people she never got on stage. 18. Michelle says brand emails should offer something proprietary, not just “one graphic and one call to action,” and she dislikes repetitive promotional blasts. 19. Safaya frames the conversation as a practical interview with coaching, examples from her own list, and references to segmentation ideas from other guests. 20. People running a service business with a large unused list will get the most from this episode, while anyone wanting a high-level branding chat may skip it.

As heard by us

A practical reset for freelancers, service providers, and business owners who want email to feel more manageable.

Email marketing comes across as a more personal channel than social, and the discussion is strongest when it gets concrete. Dr. Safaya and Michelle Wintersteen spend time on audience buckets, analytics, and the split between people who came in for a free resource and people who…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when your master list feels like one messy bucket.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on