ELI5 Explain Like I'm 5: Bite sized answers to stuff you should know about - in a mini podcast · ELI5 Explain Like I'm Five Podcast

ELI5 Xmas - why some say Happy Christmas vs Merry Christmas (part 1)?

December 19, 2025·10 min·1 clip

Why do Americans say 'Merry Christmas' while Brits say 'Happy Christmas,' and when did this Victorian-era split begin?

The episode begins with host Tim introducing guest Brian Earl, host of the Christmas Past podcast, to answer listener questions about Christmas traditions. The first topic is the linguistic difference between 'Merry Christmas' in America and 'Happy Christmas' in the UK. Brian explains that this split emerged during the Victorian period, when 'merry' was associated with low-class, raucous partying, and the Victorians sought to domesticate Christmas into a family-centered holiday. He notes that King George V's 'Merry Christmas' radio addresses helped popularize the phrase in America, while it faded in the UK. The conversation then shifts to the origins of red and green Christmas colors. Brian traces this to ancient winter celebrations, where evergreens like holly were used for decoration and believed to have special properties. He clarifies that red and green weren't always dominant, with blue and gold also used historically, and credits early 20th-century media and corporations like Coca-Cola for standardizing these colors through advertising. Next, the episode covers the evolution of Santa Claus. Brian describes Santa's origins in Saint Nicholas, a 4th-century saint from Myra (modern Turkey) known for miracles like resurrecting the dead. Over time, Santa absorbed elements from Northern European folk myths, becoming an elf-like figure. The modern image of a grandfatherly Santa in a red suit was solidified in the 1930s by artist Haddon Sundblom for Coca-Cola ads. Finally, the discussion turns to Christmas gift-giving. Brian links this tradition to the Victorian era and the Industrial Revolution, which produced more goods and a rising middle class. He explains that media coverage of royal Christmases, including Prince Albert's Christmas tree, inspired middle-class families to adopt these practices, making gift-giving a central part of the holiday. The episode ends with a preview of part two, which will address Christmas songs and NORAD's Santa tracking.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from ELI5 Explain Like I'm 5: Bite sized answers to stuff you should know about - in a mini podcast