EarzUp!

Mattel vs. Hasbro: The Battle of the Disney Princesses

·1 hr 1 min·5 clips
Mattel lost its Disney princess license in 2016, but got it back just six years later, causing stock swings.
The show starts nowhere near a corporate toy battle. Halloween has arrived early, at least according to a musty shirt pulled from storage. That detour brings vacuum bags, neighborhood decorations, and enormous skeletons with clown hair. Eventually, the toy talk begins. Hasbro is remembered as a leader of the 1980s, and the hosts run through familiar properties before pausing for personal damage reports. One Jem doll goes into the bath on day one and loses its light-up earrings. The tragedy has held up remarkably well. Mattel's side brings Barbie, Hot Wheels, Fisher-Price, Matchbox, Uno, Polly Pocket, and Thomas & Friends into the conversation. Hot Wheels and Matchbox sharing a corporate home still feels slightly odd. The comparison also reaches licensed properties such as Disney and Pixar's Cars, Frozen, Harry Potter, Hello Kitty and Friends, and Minecraft. Then the calendar jumps to 2000. Recently hired Disney executive Andy Mooney attends Disney on Ice with his family after being encouraged to experience the company's properties. The hosts know exactly how that kind of corporate encouragement sounds. At the show, Mooney spots children wearing princess gear their families made themselves. He asks mothers whether they would buy those products if Disney sold them. The answer is easy enough to read. Parents, as the hosts put it, are ready to outsource the costumes, props, and toys. The stranger part is how late Disney appears to notice the opportunity. From there, the Disney Princess line takes over a loose, joke-filled conversation about toys, licensing, and the companies behind them.

As heard by us

Disney Princess merchandising history mixes with toy nostalgia and cheerfully skeptical table talk.

Disney Princess merchandising history gives way to a warm tour of major toy brands. The hosts revisit Mattel names such as Barbie, Hot Wheels, Matchbox, and Polly Pocket, and recall Hasbro as the perceived leader of the 1980s.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You'll follow the Disney Princess merchandise idea from homemade costumes at Disney on Ice to the launch of the princess line.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on