E-Commerce Growth For Supplement Brands | Direct-to-Consumer Marketing Strategies · Bobby Hewitt

The Rising CAC Opportunity: Why Higher Customer Acquisition Costs Signal Growth in Supplement Businesses

August 31, 2025·36 min·10 clips
Bobby Hewitt opens by reconnecting this installment to the earlier discussion of average order value, cost of acquisition, and lifetime value. He builds the episode around a counterintuitive point that many marketers still resist. Lower CAC is not always the right target. In some supplement businesses, a higher CAC can signal that the brand has enough economic room to scale more aggressively. He explains that when average order value rises, the business may be able to support a more forceful acquisition approach. That shifts the ceiling for growth. He then turns to Meta as the main example. The platform's algorithm tends to reward efficiency constraints by narrowing delivery to the easiest wins. If the advertiser insists on very low CAC, the system can keep the brand in a smaller lane. Hewitt describes that as a kind of prison because it limits reach and volume. The business may be trading growth for efficiency without realizing it. The better question, in his view, is what the business can actually afford. If lifetime value is strong enough, a higher CAC may be the smarter trade. He walks through how that changes bidding behavior. Higher bids can unlock broader audiences. They can also open premium placements at peak usage times. He contrasts narrow interest targeting with broader categories and lookalike audiences. The point is not reckless spending. The point is to buy more inventory when the numbers justify it. He uses a simple scaling example to make the logic concrete. A supplement brand spending around $80,000 a month may feel capped if its CAC target is too low. At a $34 CAC, the available customer volume can be tightly constrained. If the business can truly afford something closer to $78, the operating range changes. A move toward a $65 CAC can create more room to spend. That room matters because growth is not always linear. Hewitt says the result can be exponential once the account stops trying to win through extreme efficiency alone. The brand can move from cautious targeting to a much wider field of demand. He returns repeatedly to the same contrast. The standard version of the strategy is to protect CAC at all costs. The better version is to connect CAC to the economics that actually support scale. Throughout, he turns a technical media-buying topic into plain business language. He keeps tying platform mechanics back to the reality of supplement operators who want more volume. The episode closes by pushing listeners to ask whether they can afford higher CAC, or whether they can afford to keep limiting growth by avoiding it.

As heard by us

Higher CAC can be a growth signal when AOV and LTV support it.

The episode treats rising CAC as a signal, not a failure on its own. If AOV and LTV can carry the load, a higher acquisition cost can justify broader bidding, wider reach, and more spend on Meta.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the case for paying more per customer without killing scale.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on