E-Commerce Growth For Supplement Brands | Direct-to-Consumer Marketing Strategies · Bobby Hewitt

The Insurance Gaps That Sink Supplement Brands

January 25, 2026·43 min·2 clips
A quote can be a third of the price if the product is misclassified.
1. Health Supplement Business Mastery discusses supplement-brand insurance with Michael Zendrovich on Creative Thirst / Health Business Mastery. 2. Bobby Hewitt hosts the conversation, and Michael Zendrovich is the guest because he specializes in insurance for supplements. 3. The episode asks what supplement brands actually need to insure, and how bad classification can leave a policy useless. 4. Zendrovich says brands are on the hook for product claims even when a white-label manufacturer makes the supplement. 5. He explains that general liability often includes products liability, but only if the policy is written correctly. 6. He contrasts a supplement brand selling online with a physical store like GNC, where premises liability matters differently. 7. He says premises-only coverage is aimed at slip-and-fall risk, not product injury claims. 8. He uses creatine gummies as an example and says a consumer taking an entire bag at once could create an adverse reaction claim. 9. He says a lawsuit can come from many angles, including a cut while opening the bottle. 10. He describes how insurance defense works when a claim is coverable and an attorney is assigned through the insurer. 11. He warns that some brands hire their own attorney and spend months on fees because they do not understand insurance defense. 12. He says recall coverage can sometimes be included on a general liability policy depending on the risk and product. 13. He says Amazon can require liability insurance at certain sales tiers, and Shopify sometimes asks for it as well. 14. He classifies products as high risk, medium risk, or low risk, with Kava and Kratom used as examples of problem ingredients. 15. He says applications ask about good manufacturing practices, and weak answers can raise premiums because the carrier takes on more risk. 16. He gives a gummy-brand example where an online quote was one-third of his quote because the earlier policy classified the product as candy or food manufacturing. 17. He says the application should list BPC 157, cannabis, or other specific ingredients when they are part of the product line. 18. The conversation stays practical and advisory, with Bobby asking follow-up questions and Michael repeatedly emphasizing written disclosure. 19. Brands selling supplements, gummies, or pet supplements will get the most from this episode. 20. Listeners wanting entertainment or unrelated consumer insurance probably can skip it.

As heard by us

A clear-eyed look at why supplement insurance risk usually lands on the brand.

Michael Zendrovich draws a clear line between the brand and the insurer: the brand is the one making the claims, so it is also the one left carrying the risk when something goes wrong.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Protect your supplement brand before a cheap policy leaves you exposed.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on