Dynasty Baseball Pickups · Taylor Corso, Kyle Sonntag, Enrico Matasa

Episode 84: Buy/Sell/Hold

March 9, 2025·57 min·5 clips

Kyle and Taylor discuss their big league breakout predictions from last season and what to do with them in 2025.

This episode of Dynasty Baseball Pickups is a retrospective analysis of the hosts' 2024 breakout predictions for MLB players. Hosts Kyle Sontag and Taylor Corso, analysts from the Prospects Live platform, evaluate their past calls. They frame this evaluation through a "buy, sell, or hold" lens for dynasty fantasy baseball leagues entering the 2025 season. The hosts revisit specific players they previously identified as breakout candidates, assessing their current dynasty value. They discuss the performance outcomes for these players over the past season, using that data to inform their 2025 outlook. Kyle and Taylor provide updated stances on whether to acquire, trade, or retain each player in dynasty formats. The analysis incorporates observations and statistical trends from the recent spring training period. They reference the deep prospecting tools available at Prospects Live, like the 1300-player Dynasty list and the Trade Analyzer. The episode also includes general news and notes from the week's spring training games and developments. A key insight is the application of a financial portfolio metaphor—buy, sell, hold—to managing a dynasty fantasy baseball roster. The analysis reveals how a player's perceived value can shift dramatically based on a single season's results versus long-term potential. The hosts demonstrate how a missed breakout prediction requires an honest reassessment of a player's underlying skills and opportunity. The conversation highlights the challenge of separating short-term spring training noise from meaningful indicators for the regular season. It underscores the importance of prospect evaluation resources in making these dynasty decisions. The episode provides a transparent look at the hosts' own hits and misses from the previous year's analysis. The tone is analytical and conversational, focused on practical fantasy strategy. The style is direct and advice-oriented, geared toward helping listeners make roster decisions. Dynasty fantasy baseball managers preparing for 2025 drafts and offseasons would find this episode immediately useful. Listeners seeking pure news updates or shallow player discussion might find the deep-dive, retrospective format less engaging.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Dynasty Baseball Pickups