Dressed: The History of Fashion · Dressed Media

The Red Menace: How Lipstick Changed the Face of American History, an interview with Ilise S. Carter, part I (Dressed Classic)

January 21, 2026·1 hr 10 min·6 clips

Martha Washington's lipstick recipe used whale earwax and alkanet root for a sheer red tint.

The archive frame matters. After a science-comedy promo and the show's welcome, Cassie Zachary and April Callahan ease listeners into a Dressed classic with a quick handoff. Then the machinery comes into view. The excerpt sits in early film, when studios relied on daylight, open skies, and steady brightness to make performers legible. Hollywood feels practical here, not mythic. The guest explains why New Jersey and Queens could not give filmmakers the same dependable light, and why Hollywood's clear skies solved a technical problem. Makeup follows the camera. Dark eyes, dark lips, and tightly drawn mouths helped faces read while film stock and lighting were still catching up. The vamp gets a bold little mouth. That bee-stung lip, placed near the center, comes out of waxy products that melted, moved, and needed control. The story stays nicely specific. The guest brings up the alleged Max Factor thumbprint explanation for the lip shape, while saying she could not confirm or disprove it. Mary Pickford gives the episode another register. For the ingenue, the penciled mouth and softer brightness kept a childlike effect with Victorian echoes still attached. Fashion did not flip overnight. The guest pushes back on the idea that everyone rushed into short hair, reminding listeners that it stayed cutting edge longer than hindsight makes it seem. Technique carries emotion here. Like stage makeup, early screen makeup exaggerated features so expression could survive the medium. Then film stock changes. Panchromatic film, used in the early twenties in this account, picked up light better and made Max Factor more decisive once older makeup began to look harsh onscreen. The pleasure is in the correction: lipstick comes across as a tool shaped by wax, sun, cameras, mouths, and faces.

As heard by us

A compact look at lipstick as image-making, studio craft, and public style.

Lipstick starts as the hook, but the conversation quickly opens onto how fashion, film, and performance kept shaping one another. The hosts keep things light, while the guest carries the history into early Hollywood, where makeup had to work harder under new cameras, bright…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for lipstick history that opens into early Hollywood makeup craft.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Dressed: The History of Fashion