Draftvice-Football Podcast- News/Analysis surrounding Fantasy Football and the NFL Draft · Brojo Deathpunch

Schoen & Daboll on the Hot Seat? | New York Giants 2025 Season Preview- Draftvice

·32 min·2 clips

Joe Shane let Saquon Barkley walk, and the trade return never materialized.

It opens on year four of the New York Football Giants administration with Joe Shane and Brian Dayball. Dayball gets the warmer read, while Shane draws more suspicion. The GM gets credit for a few solid draft hits, but some misses are part of the picture too. The Daniel Jones contract is not pinned entirely on him, since the episode suggests Mr. Mara may have been involved from above. The Barkley departure becomes the clearest example of the front office debate. Letting Saquon walk is not framed as the worst move Shane ever made. The bigger issue is that the split probably should have been handled much earlier. A trade before free agency would have made more sense, even if the return was only a third- or fourth-round pick. The fact that Barkley ended up with the Eagles and ran for 2,000 yards makes the whole thing look worse in hindsight. The compensatory pick is acknowledged, but it does not fully erase the loss. From there the episode turns to the quarterback market. Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston are both part of the conversation. Mac Jones and Jacoby Brissett come up as other possible paths the Giants could have explored. Brissett is treated as an interesting fit. Mac Jones is discussed as the kind of cheap option that might have brought locker-room questions with it. Winston gets a long look as well. He is presented as a player who can be fun to watch but is not easy to trust as a starter. His Cleveland stint is used as the cautionary example, while Flacco is brought up as the contrast because he came off a couch and helped the Browns get to the playoffs. The episode then lands on Jackson Dart. The pick is not treated as a franchise-saving move. It is treated as a relatively low-cost swing that might matter quickly if the season goes sideways. The closing note is blunt. If the Giants cannot protect the quarterback or put points on the board, the season could get long in a hurry and firings would not be a shocking outcome.

As heard by us

A blunt Giants check-in on Joe Shane, Brian Dayball, and a roster still under pressure.

The Giants come off as a year-four test of Joe Shane and Brian Dayball, with the show strongest when it weighs what has worked against what has not.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a blunt read on the Giants in year four of the Joe Shane and Brian Dayball era.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Draftvice-Football Podcast- News/Analysis surrounding Fantasy Football and the NFL Draft