Down to Birth · Cynthia Overgard & Trisha Ludwig

#347 | When Doulas Face the Unthinkable: A Return Conversation with Dynamic Doulas

December 17, 2025·46 min·3 clips

Doula Laura describes her trauma response as a nervous system pulled so tight it snaps rather than absorbs — still in that state years after a baby died at her birth.

1. Down to Birth hosts Cynthia Overgaard and Tricia Ludwig return with Sarah and Laura of Dynamic Doulas (previously episode 196) for a follow-up conversation three years later. 2. Cynthia Overgaard is a birth educator and postpartum support specialist; Tricia Ludwig is a certified nurse midwife and international board-certified lactation consultant; Sarah and Laura are co-owners of Dynamic Doulas, a doula practice that also trains other doulas. 3. The episode's core question is how doulas process and carry baby deaths they attend, and whether educational advocacy creates moral responsibility for adverse outcomes. 4. Sarah attended two baby deaths within the same three-month period: a stillbirth at 38 weeks 5 days where a baby was alive one day and gone the next with no warning signs, and a home birth where a baby's heart rate vanished with no prior decelerations and was delivered in an ambulance with no subsequent brain activity. 5. Laura attended a shoulder dystocia at a midwifery clinic involving a 42-week, nearly 12-pound baby who could not be freed and had to transfer to hospital with the head already delivered; the baby died, and family and friends had encouraged induction beforehand. 6. Sarah describes the ethical weight of being asked: would that baby be alive if you had been induced? — while acknowledging she cannot isolate the variable because shoulder dystocia is not fully predicted by gestational age or baby size. 7. Cynthia draws out the specific moral tension: when doulas educate women toward physiological birth choices and those choices precede an adverse outcome, the doula may feel responsibility even if the client made an independent, informed decision. 8. Laura describes driving the father and grandmother to the hospital following the ambulance, her biggest fear being that they were arriving not just to a dead baby but also to a dead mother, and the relief when she learned the mother had survived. 9. Laura reveals that the shoulder dystocia birth is her most valued birth she has attended professionally, explaining that she witnessed the family grieve with immense faith, compassion, and love that expanded her understanding of human capacity. 10. Sarah unpacks what Laura meant: the family knew who they needed in the room, how they needed to grieve, and expressed love so palpably that even in the worst moment it was a growth experience for Laura — who stayed ten hours because there was no natural goodbye. 11. Cynthia validates this as a genuine experience of 'holding space' in its full meaning — felt rather than used as a cliche — noting that it becomes cliche when people repeat it without feeling it. 12. Three weeks before recording, Sarah delivered a frank breech baby at 11 pounds 7 ounces without a traditional birth attendant present, performed CPR with the mother doing breaths, and felt a heartbeat return before the baby began breathing; five days passed before Sarah knew the baby had no brain damage. 13. Laura notes that after this CPR birth, she attended a subsequent birth where she found herself 'in her head,' watching for omens in contraction patterns in a way she hadn't before, a shift from her prior state of simply allowing birth to unfold. 14. Both hosts and guests identify the same conclusion: birth goes well the vast majority of the time and sometimes nothing you do changes the outcome, and the difficult choice is how much proximity to medical infrastructure reduces versus introduces its own risk. 15. Cynthia shares her own evolution over 18 years of teaching: she no longer presents birth as uniformly safe because it is an injustice to make an adverse outcome feel impossible, and she now says honestly that she doesn't know what she would do at 42 weeks facing induction — she would get quiet and look within. 16. Both Sarah and Laura describe a feeling that their training of other doulas and their work now is a way to make sense of the losses, noting they believe the universe put both deaths in their path within three months of each other for a reason. 17. The conversation is interview-style, intimate, and emotionally heavy; hosts and guests speak slowly and carefully, allowing for long pauses and redirections; sponsor reads appear at two natural breaks. 18. The format relies on the genuine personal relationship between all four women and the mutual respect Cynthia and Tricia have built with their returning guests over years. 19. Doulas, midwives, student birth workers, and mothers who have experienced birth loss will find this episode most meaningful and grounding. 20. Listeners seeking clinical how-to birth guidance, pregnancy tips, or uplifting birth content will likely find this episode too emotionally heavy for that purpose.

As heard by us

Two doulas reflect on birth loss, fear, relief, and the work of staying present.

Down to Birth lands as a plainspoken look at what it takes to keep showing up after a devastating birth outcome. Sarah and Laura of Dynamic Doulas talk openly about fear, relief, and the way hard births can change a practitioner, while Cynthia and Tricia keep the focus on…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When you want the human cost of birth work, not a polished success story.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Down to Birth