First Conviction: Bonus - Behind the Scenes

·48 min·3 clips

David Dorn says that in spring 2024, both sides' medical experts agreed 'the crime never happened.'

1. Documentary on One Podcast's First Conviction: Bonus - Behind the Scenes focuses on how RT Investigates and Documentary on One built a podcast and television documentary around one legal case. 2. Aoife Hegarty, Pamela Frayer, Philip Gallagher, Liam O'Brien, David Dorn, and Tim Desmond are named as the RT Investigates and Documentary on One team members explaining their roles. 3. The episode asks what the project was for: explaining the mechanics of the series while tracking how a live court story became a long-form investigation. 4. Liam O'Brien says the work began after he read a Saturday article in The Journal and called legal teams that same afternoon. 5. One legal contact told Liam, 'I've been waiting three and a half years to receive this phone call,' which pushed the story forward. 6. David Dorn says RT Investigates and Documentary on One had already seen the story as a fit for audio and video because it had personal, institutional, and legal strands. 7. He names the personal story, the translation-service problem in the court system, and the wider implications for other cases as the three to four components they saw early. 8. Tim Desmond says the case was difficult to tell because it was still in the courts and involved restrictions on identifying people. 9. He adds that institutions usually share information only through freedom of information requests or rights of reply, which made reporting slower. 10. Pamela Frayer says the couple were open from day one, gave them nothing off bounds, and wanted the story told so it would not happen to anyone else. 11. Frayer says she was struck by the Túsla case conference notes, which showed who attended, what was discussed, and how conclusions were drawn. 12. She says the family kept maintaining their innocence while Túsla appeared to trust the medics. 13. Tim Desmond says Saeed kept contemporaneous notes on scraps of paper, using both French and English, after asking for a pencil and paper in custody. 14. He says those notes captured prison transfers, separation from Halawa, and a short note from a chaplain saying, 'found your wife and she's okay.' 15. David Dorn says the production needed to balance FGM as a human-rights violation with the fact that the accusation against this couple was later undermined by medical evidence. 16. He says spring 2024 brought the turning point when the DPP's own medical expert agreed the crime never happened. 17. Philip Gallagher says the visual challenge was how to tell the family's story when their faces could not appear on camera and reconstruction would have been too graphic. 18. Gallagher says the team used animation with graphic designer Sean Malone, storyboards, and final-cut scenes, while Tim Desmond says the audio version used actors Steve Heartland and Isoza Iguodaro. 19. The tone is collaborative, detailed, and process-driven, with the team comparing audio, film, legal checking, rights of reply, music, and archive work. 20. People interested in investigative production, court reporting, and audio-visual collaboration would likely enjoy it, while listeners wanting a simple standalone crime recap might skip it.

As heard by us

A careful look at how a difficult case was reported, documented, and assembled.

This bonus episode unpacks how First Conviction came together, from a small article that grew into a year-long project to the reporting that drew on legal voices and official records.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want the reporting process behind a miscarriage-of-justice story?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Documentary on One Podcast