Documentary on One Podcast · RTÉ

First Conviction: 01 - The Incident

·29 min·1 clip
Hospital staff later say the wound was fresh and could cause shock within 6 to 10 hours.
1. Documentary on One's First Conviction follows the first Irish FGM prosecution through the September 2016 injury to Aisha in Dublin. 2. Ruth Naga narrates the series, while Saeed and Halawa are voiced by actors because their real identities are protected to shield Aisha. 3. The episode asks how a 21-month-old child ended up bleeding, why hospital staff suspected FGM, and how the case became a criminal investigation. 4. Saeed says he was cooking breakfast and caring for the older child while Halawa was breastfeeding the 7-week-old baby on Friday morning, 16 September 2016. 5. Halawa says Aisha needed a nappy change, and Saeed brought her toward the bathroom before she cried and blood appeared on his trousers and on the floor. 6. The parents say they thought Aisha may have fallen on a toy, then decided to drive to Crumlin Children's Hospital to have her checked. 7. Hospital records cited in the episode say Aisha was admitted at 11.57am, and CCTV shows her moving between chairs, playing peekaboo, and dancing. 8. A nurse and doctor first told Saeed that Aisha did not appear to have anything wrong, but he insisted the hospital examine her further because he feared an internal injury. 9. A surgeon later arrived at 5pm, described the bleeding as brisk, and cauterised the wound after Aisha was taken into theatre with anaesthetic drops. 10. Saeed says he was told the injury involved the genital area, that no stitches were needed, and that Aisha would stay in hospital for observation. 11. Child-protection procedures began after hospital staff raised concerns about a non-accidental injury under the Children First Act. 12. Shane Dunphy explains that hospital staff must contact the designated liaison person quickly when an injury does not fit the account given by parents. 13. Tusla then reviewed the file, examined the injury, and helped lead the child-protection response while medical staff continued treatment. 14. At a Tuesday meeting, Saeed and Halawa say consultants, social workers, and Tusla staff challenged their account and asked whether they could tell a different story. 15. Halawa says a Tusla officer first used the words female genital mutilation, which she says she had never expected to hear in her life. 16. The episode says Halawa had experienced FGM as a child in East Africa and had told hospital staff she was openly against the practice. 17. The narration notes that Halawa had been living in Ireland for almost a decade, was an Irish citizen, and had two Irish citizen daughters born in Dublin. 18. Saeed was 34, Halawa was 24, and the episode says he was also fighting a deportation order at the time of the hospital admission. 19. The tone mixes courtroom chronology, hospital detail, and interview-led reconstruction, with medical terminology and legal procedure driving the pace. 20. Listeners who follow Irish crime, child-protection cases, and medical investigations are likely to stay with it, while anyone avoiding slow procedural detail may skip it.
Listen to the show on