Doctors of Running Podcast · Doctors of Running

#258 Marathon Shoes 101: Our Top Picks for Sub-3 and 4+ Hour Runners

·1 hr 2 min·5 clips

David chooses the Saucony Endorphin Elite 1 for its stability, even when he's not in peak shape.

This episode features Doctors of Running hosts Dr. Matt Klein and Dr. David Celeste, both physical therapists and experienced marathoners, discussing shoe selection for fall marathons. They aim to provide guidance tailored to individual runners, emphasizing the importance of choosing a shoe well before race day. The hosts begin by sharing their current test shoes, including the Rabbit High Country trail shoe, the ASICS Metaspeed Tokyo, and the Takumi Sen 11. Dr. Celeste notes the Rabbit High Country offers good security and traction, though the upper could be more comfortable and the heel could be better beveled. Dr. Klein reports nearly 100 miles on the ASICS Metaspeed Tokyo, finding its foam needed 30-40 miles to break in and become bouncy. He also mentions testing the Mizuno Wave Sky 9, which has ample cushioning and a responsive ride but a very snug upper. The conversation then shifts to marathon shoe selection, stressing the need for a predictable, trusted shoe over such a long distance. They advise runners to test their race shoe in at least one long run or long workout to ensure their body can handle it. The hosts argue that super shoes are not necessary for every runner, as many fast marathon times have been achieved in daily or lightweight trainers. Dr. Celeste points out that many racing shoes are designed with elite, sub-two-hour marathon mechanics in mind, though other runners can still use them. They propose stratifying recommendations based on a runner's goal experience, whether aiming for a PR, a comfortable finish, or simply completion. For a runner in current shape aiming to finish a marathon, Dr. Celeste selects the Saucony Endorphin Elite 1 for its stability, the ASICS Metaspeed Tokyo for its responsive yet forgiving nature, and the Nike Zoom Fly for its structured, trainer-like ride. He estimates he could run between three and three-and-a-half hours in such shoes. Dr. Klein's similar picks for the three-to-four-hour range include the ASICS Metaspeed Tokyo, the Saucony Endorphin Trainer for its balanced foam, and the softer, less aggressive Saucony Endorphin Speed 5. For runners targeting four hours or more, the focus shifts entirely to comfort and reliability over a very long time on feet. Dr. Celeste and Dr. Klein both highlight the ASICS Gel-Kayano as a top stability choice for this group, trusting its design for completion-focused efforts. The tone is conversational and educational, blending personal anecdotes with practical advice. This episode is ideal for marathoners of all levels seeking detailed shoe recommendations and rationale, while those looking for in-depth reviews of specific new models may find the initial gear-check segment most relevant.

As heard by us

A practical marathon-shoe check-in that weighs pace, structure, and fit over hype.

The episode treats marathon shoe selection as a practical decision for fall racing, and the hosts make a decent case for choosing early instead of waiting until the last week.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Sort out your marathon shoe before race-week panic kicks in.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Doctors of Running Podcast