Divorce Court · Divorce Court

S27E74: Falling for the Same Excuse: Wyisha Toston vs. Wesley Townsley Part 1

·24 min·2 clips
Wyisha found texts proving her fiancé is secretly engaged to another woman three days before their wedding.
Ms. Tolston says she is finished with her fiance's behavior. She believes he has been lying and stepping out on her. The relationship goes all the way back to high school. They have been together for 10 years. They also have two little girls together. Judge Starr makes it clear this is not just a private dispute. The children are part of the picture too. Ms. Tolston says she is tired of the shenanigans. She wants the truth, not another story. She says if the lie detector says he is lying, that will tell her everything she needs to know. Mr. Townsend starts by answering the court's questions about the length of the relationship. Then the story takes a sharp turn. He says he and a best friend ran a scheme with another woman. He explains that the friend handled the conversation while he added the details. He admits he was helping sell a story to get money. Judge Starr presses him on what kind of man tries to hustle one woman in order to benefit another. She makes it plain that the behavior is not a small mistake. She calls out the lack of character in the setup. He tries to minimize it by saying he did not have sex with the woman. The court is not interested in that as a clean defense. The conversation stays focused on the dishonesty itself. Ms. Tolston keeps comparing his behavior to the kind of betrayal that changes how you see a person. She describes him as a walking red flag. The confrontation widens the case from cheating suspicion to a broader pattern of deception. The episode then moves toward the polygraph. The test asks whether he has had sexual contact with anyone other than Ms. Tolston since 2017. The result is not fully revealed here, but the pressure is obvious. The setup makes the relationship feel less like a misunderstanding and more like a long chain of excuses. Every answer is treated like a chance to clear the air or sink deeper. The pacing stays brisk and confrontational. The court keeps pulling the story back to the one question that matters most. Can either of them tell the truth straight through, without spinning it? The episode closes by leaving that answer hanging in the balance.

As heard by us

Cheating accusations, a catfishing confession, and a polygraph keep the case moving.

A high school sweetheart couple lands in Divorce Court over cheating accusations, and the episode gets its charge from how fast the story moves from romance to a catfishing confession and a polygraph test.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a Divorce Court showdown with receipts, cheater talk, and a polygraph.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on