Divorce Court · Divorce Court

S27E67: Buffing Out the Truth: Elizabeth Sivers vs. Steven Sivers

·24 min·2 clips
Polygraph results show Mr. Sivers lied about sexual contact, shocking his wife in court.
Mrs. Cypress arrives with divorce papers and a long list of doubts. She thinks her husband has been using his auto detailing business as cover for something else. The details never line up. Money goes missing. He stays on his phone. He leaves for detailing jobs and comes back with explanations that do not satisfy her. Judge Starr asks for the practical version of events, not the polished one. Mr. Cypress says detailing can mean sporadic hours and that he can set his own schedule. He also says he once had to return most of a client’s money because he did not have all the products needed to finish the job. Mrs. Cypress does not buy it. She says she has heard too many explanations like this to believe they are accidents. Lucky, the couple’s dog, comes up as part of the household details. Mrs. Cypress says even the small things in their life feel suspicious now. The judge keeps pressing the same point. If the business is real, why does the story keep sounding like a cover. Mrs. Cypress says she is tired of being lied to. She says she cannot stay in the relationship unless he tells the truth. Mr. Cypress pushes back and insists the work is legitimate. The whole exchange keeps circling the same gap between what he says and what she sees. Judge Starr refuses to let the case drift into vague hurt feelings. He names the pattern directly. He tells Mr. Cypress he is a liar and a cheater, and says he has treated her poorly. He also tells Mrs. Cypress that until she cares enough about herself, she will keep getting lied to and cheated on. The court does not force a divorce on the spot. Instead, the judge makes it clear that Mrs. Cypress has to decide whether she is ready to walk away for good.

As heard by us

Judge Starr keeps the Cypress divorce dispute centered on whether the husband's explanations hold up.

A marriage built on denials and side-eye gets the full Judge Starr treatment as Mrs. Cypress presses her husband over what looks like more than routine work from his auto detailing business.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want Judge Starr to cut through the phone-checking and shaky explanations, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on