Divorce Court · Divorce Court

S27E66: Anxiety Beach: Nicole Serrano vs. Peter Plemons

·24 min·2 clips
Peter fails the lie detector test, exposing his infidelity and causing Nicole to end their engagement.
Nicole Serrano says Peter Plemons has been setting off red flags for a long time. She says he lies and then turns around and blames her anxiety and paranoia. Peter says he has been concerned about her for the last month and a half. He says her anxiety can get debilitating, especially when they are out with friends and it gets so bad that they have to leave. Nicole wants a lie detector test. If he fails, she says she is gone. Peter says her accusations are not grounded in reality. The judge asks why they are in court at all. Nicole says she is tired of being treated like she is imagining things. Peter says the problem is new and that she has lately been saying things that have not happened. One story centers on Nicole claiming Peter had an erection around particular students. Peter says that never happened. Nicole says she confronted him about it anyway. Peter says the explanation he gave was ordinary, that morning erections happen, and that this was the first time he had ever heard the claim. Another story centers on Peter’s studio. Nicole says she went there at night and found it locked. She says she knocked, heard voices, laughter, and a woman inside, and took that as proof that he was with someone else. Peter says he does not know what she is talking about. He says he suggested she see a psychiatrist about a month and a half earlier because he was worried about her. Nicole says he has been pushing the idea that she is crazy. Peter denies trying to do that. The judge keeps pulling the fight back to practical terms: who said what, who heard what, and what follows from the facts. By the end, the judge tells Nicole she does need therapy, but not for the reason Peter gave. He frames it as a chance to clear herself from the need to get her identity through somebody else who is not worthy of her, learn her triggers, finish therapy, and move on with her freedom intact. The episode ends on a blunt push toward independence, with the court treating the relationship as something that has already shown its hand.

As heard by us

A messy trust fight gets pressed into common-sense judgment and comes out sharper for it.

A fiance dispute turns into a steady test of trust, anxiety, and who gets to frame the truth. Nicole Serrano says Peter Plemons lied and used her anxiety and paranoia against her, while he says her anxiety has become debilitating and that she is insisting on events that never…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When a lie detector test becomes the last word in a four-year engagement, Divorce Court gets blunt fast.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on