Divorce Court · Divorce Court

S27E64: The Private and the Dancer: Lyshala "Shay" Lewis vs. Alisha Jones

·24 min·2 clips
The polygraph test shows Ms. Jones lied about cheating, shattering eight years of trust.
Ms. Lewis says she still loves Ms. Jones, but she does not trust her anymore. She tells Judge Starr that the relationship has been strained by bad choices, money trouble, and a little infidelity. She wants the lie detector to show whether Ms. Jones has been deceitful, and says the relationship should end if the test shows deception. The case is framed as an eight-year relationship under heavy strain, with children from earlier relationships making everything feel even more loaded. The show keeps coming back to one question: are the two women still working from the same facts? Judge Starr pushes for plain answers instead of vague promises. The tension centers on specific events that damaged trust, including a staycation where Ms. Jones said she was going to the store, disappeared for hours, and later admitted she had gone dancing at a club. The episode also revisits an earlier crisis involving jail, children upstairs, and a bounty hunter at the window, which shows how much disruption Ms. Lewis has already put up with. Judge Starr draws a sharp moral line between the two women, calling Ms. Lewis honest and loyal while saying Ms. Jones has not been truthful. He also suggests Ms. Jones has used her looks to get what she wants from people. The ruling is blunt and unsentimental: Ms. Lewis is told not to keep rescuing the relationship at her own expense. The episode ends with the truth out in the open, and the harder part left hanging: what to do with it.

As heard by us

A trust-frayed Divorce Court dispute that moves from lies and infidelity to a blunt judgment.

This Divorce Court case is built on trust, and it does not take long to see why it falls apart. Ms. Lewis says Ms. Jones's lies and deception have broken that trust, while the dispute keeps coming back to money, a little infidelity, and the strain of sharing a home.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a fast, no-nonsense trust blowup in Divorce Court, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on