Distillations | Science History Institute

IVF: An Interview with Robin Marantz

·44 min·4 clips

A 19th-century doctor secretly inseminated an unconscious woman with a medical student's sperm, sparking ethical debates that still echo today.

The episode begins with a promo for Lost Women of Science before host Alexis Pedrick introduces the interview with Robin Marantz Henig. Henig defines IVF as in vitro fertilization, distinguishing it from artificial insemination by donor. She recounts the first known case of AID in 19th-century Philadelphia, where Dr. Pankost inseminated an unconscious woman without consent, highlighting early ethical violations. Henig draws parallels between IVF and Greek mythology, referencing Prometheus and Frankenstein to discuss knowledge as dangerous and dual-use technology. The slippery slope argument in bioethics is examined, with Henig noting it's a fallacy but acknowledging IVF enabled later technologies like cloning. The 1960s-70s are described as a 'wild west' for IVF research due to lack of NIH funding and bioethical oversight. Landrum Shettles is profiled as a brilliant but odd physician who did pop science and claimed early IVF successes without proper records. Robert Edwards is contrasted as a more traditional scientist at Cambridge who collaborated with Patrick Steptoe, an obstetrician providing eggs via laparoscopy. The Delzio couple's failed 1973 IVF attempt with Shettles is detailed, including the husband handing eggs in a hallway and the embryo being destroyed by Shettles' boss, Raymond Vandeville. Leslie Brown's successful 1978 pregnancy resulted in Louise Brown, the first test-tube baby, which relieved scientists and captured global media attention. The Delzios sued Columbia University, with their trial coinciding with Louise Brown's birth. Howard and Georgiana Jones established the first U.S. IVF clinic in Virginia, adhering to strict rules like using only married couples and single embryos to appease critics. The first American IVF baby, Elizabeth Carr, was born in 1981, with Jones prepared for either a healthy or tragic outcome. Henig connects IVF to modern issues like CRISPR and germline editing, expressing concern about where to draw ethical lines. The episode concludes with credits and information about the Science History Institute.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Distillations | Science History Institute