Distillations | Science History Institute

Bad Blood, Bad Science

·59 min·5 clips

Lily Tyson Head, daughter of a study participant, explains why the Tuskegee myth fueled Black Americans' COVID-19 vaccine fears.

The episode opens by addressing the common misconception that the Tuskegee study involved injecting Black men with syphilis, a myth that influenced COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. Lily Tyson Head, daughter of participant Freddie Lee Tyson, corrects the study's name, emphasizing it was a U.S. Public Health Service study, not a Tuskegee one. The narrative traces the study's origins, detailing how doctors targeted Black men in Macon County, Alabama, due to high syphilis rates and lack of healthcare. It explains the racist medical theory that syphilis affected Black people differently, causing heart issues rather than neurological ones. The episode describes the deception: men were told they had 'bad blood' and given placebos like tonics and aspirin. Key figures like Dr. Talaferro Clark and Raymond Vondelier are identified as architects of the study. The role of Black nurse Eunice Rivers is explored, showing how she gained trust while facilitating the study. The discovery of penicillin in 1943 is highlighted, noting how researchers continued the study despite a cure. The Nuremberg Code's failure to stop the study is discussed. Whistleblowers like Bill Jenkins and Peter Buxton are profiled, revealing their efforts to expose the unethical practices. The Associated Press broke the story in 1972, leading to public outrage. In 1997, President Clinton apologized to surviving participants. The episode concludes by critiquing how the study is often oversimplified, arguing that systemic racism and medical untrustworthiness are broader issues. It ends with Diane Rowley's push for the Milbank Memorial Fund's apology in 2022.

As heard by us

Tuskegee is revisited as both history and myth, with Nurse Rivers and the study's human details kept firmly in view.

This episode revisits Tuskegee and the myths around it, then follows how the study and its public story were shaped by public health ideas about race. It gives real weight to Nurse Rivers and Dr.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get the Tuskegee story, with Nurse Rivers and Dr. Dibble in the frame.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Distillations | Science History Institute