playnext.fm

Discography Discussion

Episode 233: Emery with Bryan Patton of As The Story Grows - Discography Discussion

·1 hr 8 min·5 clips
Do you think early Emery and Underøath's 'They're Only Chasing Safety' are in the same genre or league?
The episode begins with the hosts introducing guest Bryan Patton and teasing a long-awaited discussion on Emery. They briefly recap a previous episode on Def Leppard and share listener tweets, including one suggesting an Iron Maiden episode. The main segment launches with each host sharing their first experiences with Emery, from online forum recommendations to music video discoveries. They analyze each album chronologically, starting with 2004's 'The Weak's End', praising its emotional screams and melodic interplay. 2005's 'The Question' is noted for its tighter production and catchier hooks, marking a shift towards rock. A debate erupts over whether Underøath's 'They're Only Chasing Safety' is metalcore or emo, comparing it to Emery's sound. 2007's 'I'm Only a Man' is discussed as a pop-oriented risk that commercially flopped but is now a fan favorite. 2009's 'In Shallow Seas We Sail' is seen as a return to heavier sounds, described as a 'middle finger' to fans. 2011's 'We Do What We Want' is highlighted for its heaviness and dark lyrics, with Brian calling it his favorite. 2015's 'You Were Never Alone' is noted for its biblical themes and lack of cohesion. 2018's 'Eve' sparks discussion about its controversial nude artwork and adult contemporary emo style. 2020's 'White Line Fever' is described as a chill, relaxed record. The episode concludes with final thoughts on Emery's broader impact, including their podcasts, label, and cryptocurrency, and the hosts share their albums of the week.

As heard by us

A lively Emery discussion that turns a metalcore debate into a case for the band's songwriting.

Emery's mid-2000s metalcore reputation gets a thoughtful second look in this lively PlayNext conversation with Brian Patton of As the Story Grows.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play when Emery's place near the metalcore conversation feels like an argument worth settling over endless hot wings.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on
Apple PodcastsSpotify
Play clips from this episodeMore from Discography Discussion