Can business save South Africa?

·1 hr 22 min·5 clips

Wanang Mohale says South Africa stole 1.5 trillion rand during the first five years of state capture.

1. Democracy Unplugged centers on the question 'Can business save South Africa?' and Justice Malala links it to a Business for South Africa press conference and Johannesburg’s collapse. 2. Malala introduces Pete Leroux, Moelet Mbeki, Herman Mashaba, and Wanang Mohale as the panel, and each guest matters because all four sit at the intersection of business and politics. 3. The episode’s core question is whether business should help rescue the state, or whether that idea confuses private power with public responsibility. 4. Mbeki argues that business is South Africa’s most trusted institution, citing an Edelman trust survey, while government and political parties rank among the least trusted. 5. He says many major South African companies are owned by citizens, not foreign multinationals, and gives First National Bank as an example of a British bank bought through Rand Merchant Bank. 6. Mbeki uses that ownership pattern to argue that local business has a vested interest in making South Africa work. 7. He also says business is the most organized social partner and can manage megaprojects on time, on budget, and in full. 8. Mashaba says his three years as mayor of Johannesburg uncovered 35 billion rand of fraud and corruption, and he says some cases were 'as clear as daylight.' 9. He says he expropriated 154 buildings from criminal syndicates, leased them to the private sector, and expected 32 billion rand in investment, 22,000 permanent jobs, and 14,000 housing units. 10. Mashaba argues that big business worked with 'dark forces' and ANC leadership to remove him after he pursued corruption. 11. Mohale accepts that business has been complicit in corruption and says South Africa destroyed a 150-year-old institution because of greed. 12. He says business and corrupt politicians are linked because 'for every corruptor there's a corruptee,' and he places state capture at a scale of 1.5 trillion rand in the first five years. 13. Mohale says 700 million rand could eliminate 141 pit-latrine toilets in Limpopo or hire 800 unemployed doctors in Gauteng. 14. He argues that business still has credibility to earn if it transforms itself, especially on gender representation and pay parity. 15. Pete Leroux pushes back against blanket blame and says South Africa’s mess comes from political decisions rather than business alone. 16. Leroux argues that business should press back against harmful policy over the next 10 years, rather than take over state functions like railways or ports. 17. He says policy choices such as BEE and employment equity quotas are harmful, and he argues that business should challenge them in the public interest. 18. The tone is argumentative and free-flowing, with Malala repeatedly interrupting, redirecting, and pressing the panel on contradictions. 19. People interested in South African business, corruption, and state capacity will get the most from this discussion. 20. Listeners wanting a light or purely technical policy chat will probably skip it.

As heard by us

A blunt discussion about whether business should step in when government falls short.

It makes a plain case for asking whether business should step in when Johannesburg is falling apart, or whether that only blurs the line between elected duty and private influence.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want the case for whether business should step in where government is failing, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Democracy Unplugged