Why Most Leaders Fail at Building Trust (and How to Fix It) with Mike Robbins

·41 min·4 clips

John Rennie reveals why most leaders fail at building trust and how to avoid this trap.

This episode examines why leaders struggle to build trust and how to foster high-performing teams. Host John Rennie, a former submarine officer and business leader, is joined by Mike Robbins, a former professional baseball player and author specializing in emotional intelligence. They explore the practical behaviors that differentiate successful teams. Robbins contrasts great teams that talk directly to each other with struggling teams where people talk about each other. The conversation identifies avoiding difficult discussions as a common instinct that undermines trust. Building psychological safety is presented as a critical foundation for team performance. The hosts draw parallels between the dynamics of professional sports teams and those in business environments. Robbins shares his personal aversion to initiating hard conversations despite knowing their importance. The episode promises actionable advice for leaders at any level to lead with more confidence. A core argument is that most leaders fail at this specific trust-building aspect. A key insight is that the natural human tendency is to avoid or gloss over conflict to maintain superficial positivity. Robbins states his first instinct is not to proactively hash things out. The premise that leadership is fundamentally a "people business" frames all subsequent advice. The episode suggests that moving past this avoidance is a deliberate skill, not an innate trait. The comparison to sports implies trust is built through consistent, practiced communication rituals. An interesting claim is that wanting to have tough conversations is insufficient without overcoming instinctual resistance. The idea of "psychological safety" is presented as the environment where honest dialogue can occur. The tone is conversational and instructional, blending personal anecdotes with broader principles. The style is direct and aimed at providing practical, real-world leadership strategies. Leaders and managers seeking concrete methods to improve team dynamics would find this episode valuable. Listeners preferring theoretical or academic leadership discourse might find it less engaging.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Deep Leadership