7. Mystery Men

May 28, 2018·35 min·2 clips

A former KGB spy school graduate says the Isdal woman almost certainly was not a Soviet spy — too many fake identities, and Soviet field agents would smell of Chanel No. 5, not garlic.

The trail begins in teeth. Isotope results from the Isdal woman have reached Jurien Hoegewerf at the University of Canberra in Australia, where food and water traces can point to where someone grew up. The science is big, but the episode does not stay there for long. Hoegewerf says the work makes him think like an astrophysicist, a chemist, and a physicist, while still serving a forensic identification case. Then the story tightens around the Hotel Neptune. The hosts bring Lilian back to the place tied to her old witness memory, and the room still has a grip on her. Forty-seven years later, she remembers the chair, the grey hair, and the feeling that the woman and the man were arguing rather than having a pleasant dinner. She does not even want to sit where the Isdal woman sat. Then comes the part that lands hardest: Lilian reads her police statement, and the dinner with the man is not there. The hosts sit with that absence. They call it the only evidence police had been given that pointed to another individual, then ask why it was not pursued or properly written down. The documents show a thorough investigation, which makes this silence feel even stranger. Mari and Neil keep moving through the hotel, toward the woman's room and another worker's memory of her clothes and the room itself. The episode leaves the case hanging between forensic promise, witness memory, and the uncomfortable chance that someone important slipped past the record.

As heard by us

A careful hotel-side chapter built around a missing witness detail.

Death in Ice Valley keeps its investigative pace here, moving from isotope work to hotel testimony as Mari and Neil trace the people and places around the mystery.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A cold-case lead turns on a hotel room, a witness, and what the file forgot.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Death in Ice Valley