DataKnightmare: L'algoritmico è politico

DK 8x11 - La "privacy di carta"

·17 min·1 clip

Walter Vannini reveals how companies fake quality certifications, calling it 'paper quality,' and asks if you've ever encountered it.

The episode opens by drawing an analogy between 'paper quality' in ISO 9000 certifications and 'paper privacy' in data compliance, where companies perform audits without changing practices. Vannini describes how certification audits involve displaying documentation that is then archived, with no real process improvement. He introduces a specific example: a 24-page GDPR compliance module from a major consulting firm, obtained via a friend. The module's description of data treatment starts only on page 15 and spans nine pages of multiple-choice questions. Vannini contrasts this with the GDPR's definition of data treatment, which lists 13 categories but can be summarized simply. He notes the module expands this to 16 non-exclusive categories and includes 22 separate choices for personal data types, like splitting date of birth, place of birth, and tax code. The host suggests this pedantry might be the work of a generative AI, as it lacks human boredom and produces meaningless detail. He argues the module's real purpose is to avoid actual supplier audits, shifting responsibility to the data controller. Vannini then connects this to broader trends, citing AI assistants in Google Workspace and Microsoft Office that generate content quickly, leading recipients to use AI to summarize it. He calls this 'Microsoft's level of optimization,' where AI solves problems it creates. The episode concludes that 'paper privacy' fits an economic model focused on producing more, not better, where compliance forms obscure actual data practices. Vannini signs off by noting the show is ad-free due to moral objections to data economy and targeted advertising.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from DataKnightmare: L'algoritmico è politico