Show 320 - Steering Into the Iceberg

September 20, 2020·1 hr 13 min·5 clips

Dan Carlin, who has voted third-party since 1992, announces he is voting for Joe Biden because Trump will steer into the civil war iceberg.

He begins personally. The host understands why listeners want him to speak, because the times feel wickedly fraught and silence has become part of the question. His old line about wisdom needing a flexible mind stops sounding like a motto and starts sounding like a test. Can he really adjust when the evidence strains what he thought was true? From there, the episode turns to power. He argues that both parties accepted extraordinary tools when their own side had them, and over time those laws and powers piled up. Each camp excused its own uses, trusting that responsible presidents would handle dangerous authority responsibly. That comfort depended on character. Presidents were supposed to be vetted by the system, steadied by the office, and held in place by protocol during a crisis. That assumption no longer holds. If someone reaches office without that restraint, powers once sold as safeguards begin to look ominous. The warning is not aimed in only one direction. If Trump supporters welcome those powers now, the host says they had better hope this is the last president, because the precedent will not stay with one side. Patriotism becomes the test. He presses the clash between anti-authoritarian constitutional language and support for a leader whose friends talk about martial law, hanging corporate figures, and sedition trials for generals. The tone gets darker as he frames the choice as reckless flirtation with civil war or personal gain pursued with careless risk to the republic. Franklin closes it out. The old line about having a republic if you can keep it suddenly feels less like trivia and more like the whole point.

As heard by us

Carlin turns emergency powers and partisan hypocrisy into a bleak question about whether the republic can still restrain power.

Dan Carlin opens with a confession that the political moment has forced him to test his own assumptions. He is not just warning about Trump; he is worrying aloud about whether a mind built around flexibility can survive a truly foundational adjustment.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you've wondered how emergency powers became a normal political tool, this is the hour you've been avoiding.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Dan Carlin's Common Sense