Culture Gabfest · Slate Podcasts

Heathcliff, It’s Me Cathy Edition

February 18, 2026·52 min·2 clips
Amy Nicholson says Fennell’s gallows opening promises a sex-and-violence film that never quite arrives.
1. Culture Gabfest’s “Heathcliff, It’s Me Cathy” edition reviews Emerald Fennell’s Wuthering Heights and FX’s Love Story, then introduces a Muppet Show special. 2. Host Dana Stevens is joined by LA Times film critic Amy Nicholson and New York Times Opinion columnist Jamel Bowie, whose criticism shapes the film and Kennedy-family discussions. 3. Nicholson and Stevens argue Fennell’s adaptation trades Emily Brontë’s intergenerational violence and Heathcliff’s racial ambiguity for an adult-cast lust romance. 4. Nicholson praises the film’s opening hanging scene but says its later eroticism feels tame, while the panel discusses a barn scene involving servants’ sexual horseplay. 5. Bowie says casting Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi as Catherine and Heathcliff obscures the young ages behind the novel’s consequential decisions. 6. Stevens says omitting Wuthering Heights’ next generation also removes the novel’s depiction of violence passing between generations. 7. Nicholson says Brontë left Heathcliff’s background and the lovers’ sexuality open to interpretation, while Fennell chooses to emphasize sex rather than race. 8. Love Story opens with John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bissette’s 1999 plane crash, then flashes back to their 1993 meeting at Calvin Klein’s store. 9. Bowie questions the Kennedys’ celebrity status, while Nicholson points to the series’ focus on Carolyn’s discomfort with paparazzi and public attention. 10. Viewers of film adaptations, literary criticism, and celebrity television.
Listen to the show on