Crossing Broadcast: A Philly Sports Show

Crossing Broadcast: "New Year, New You" + Saquon Sits - January 2nd, 2025

·50 min·5 clips

Should the Eagles risk Saquon Barkley's health for a single-season rushing record in a meaningless finale?

The episode opens by framing the central controversy: whether Saquon Barkley should risk injury in a meaningless Week 18 game to chase Eric Dickerson's NFL single-season rushing record. The hosts share anecdotes about friendly Cowboys fans in Texas before diving into the Eagles' recent win over Dallas, noting Kenny Pickett played with broken ribs. They dissect the Barkley dilemma, arguing that playing him would require the entire starting offensive line to also play, increasing injury risk before the playoffs. A detailed statistical comparison shows Barkley had 2,005 yards on 345 carries (5.8 YPC), while Dickerson had 2,105 yards on 379 carries (5.6 YPC) in 1984, suggesting Barkley's season was more efficient. The host posits that valuing a Super Bowl above all else makes chasing the record illogical, as the goals are mutually exclusive. The discussion pivots to college football, analyzing Penn State's playoff run after beating SMU and Boise State. The hosts debate whether Penn State's four-game path was easier than Oregon's three-game path, considering injuries like Georgia quarterback Carson Beck's UCL issue. They critique Penn State coach James Franklin's play-calling and the team's margin for error against elite competition. The final segment covers the Philadelphia Union hiring Bradley Carnell, a coach from the Red Bull system, predicting a return to a high-pressing, physical style that relies on young academy players rather than expensive stars. The episode concludes with brief mentions of a Mark Hoagie's look-alike contest video and complaints about a jersey giveaway by Russ Joy.

As heard by us

A Saquon rushing-record debate turns into a sharp Eagles argument about risk, seeding, and timing.

Crossing Broadcast frames Saquon Barkley sitting the Eagles' season finale as exactly the kind of argument Philadelphia tends to keep alive: a division title is secured, the Super Bowl path is in view, and a rushing record is still sitting there to be argued over.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a Philly argument over Saquon Barkley, the single-season rushing record, and whether the Eagles should protect their Super Bowl chances.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Crossing Broadcast: A Philly Sports Show