Critically Acclaimed Network · William Bibbiani

Critically Acclaimed #363 | The Super Mario Galaxy Movie, The Serpent's Skin, Forbidden Fruits, The Drama

April 8, 2026·1 hr 46 min·5 clips

A grumpy chocolate CEO banned from competitions sparks a debate about Willy Wonka's true nature.

The hook starts loose. One host is back from Maui, where spring break somehow turns into a chocolate factory tour and a CEO giving off serious Wonka energy. Then Mario takes over. The Super Mario Galaxy Movie becomes the example for a defense the host seems very used to hearing whenever a bad review gets noticed. It is for kids, commenters say, so it does not have to be Citizen Kane, Shakespeare, or whatever grand standard someone wants to throw at it. The list gets absurd quickly: Christopher Nolan, The Godfather, Interstellar, Oppenheimer, Schindler's List, The Shawshank Redemption, even Megalopolis. That is the joke, but the sharper point is underneath it. The defenders keep explaining what the movie is not, while barely saying what it is. The host is not asking Mario to turn into Oscar bait or a grim prestige drama. The bar is lower and more reasonable than that. A kid's movie can have feeling. It can have a clear idea. It can give people one solid reason to defend it. By their read, this one does not. Saying it gets to be bad because children are the audience comes off lazy, and maybe a little revealing. The show stays casual, with interruptions and quick laughs, but the criticism has a spine. If the whole defense is that Mario is not Shakespeare, that is not much of a defense.

As heard by us

A Mario-movie takedown that turns comment-section comparisons into the main event.

Whitney and William start with Whitney's Hawaii trip, including a stay on Maui and a chocolate factory tour led by a grumpy CEO who, as the story goes, was barred from chocolate competitions for being too good.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want a Mario review that starts in Maui and turns a chocolate-factory stop into a grumpy little takedown.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Critically Acclaimed Network