Ep 369 "Critically Pentacles"

·1 hr 10 min·4 clips

A July 4 trip to Kerrville nearly happened hours before floods killed people there.

They start rowdy. The opening minutes move through a phone joke, a nod to The Fountain of Youth, and a running bit about episode 369 before the hosts settle into their usual tag-team rhythm. The tone stays loose. Meg 1, Rick the Rizzo, and Eric Fairenuff-Lopez trade introductions, joke about surviving the age of cancellation, and keep the pace moving with their familiar back-and-forth. Baseball takes over. They talk through where the Red Sox sit a little over .500, why Boston still feels like a place that only cares about championships, and how a few young call-ups are changing the shape of the team. The Yankees get hit hard. Injuries to the pitching staff, including another Tommy John loss, make them sound vulnerable, while the hosts keep circling back to whether the team is suddenly there for the taking. The NL gets a scan. The Dodgers are treated as a club drifting the wrong way, the Padres are still seen as a team that can get hot again, and Philadelphia comes off as the most dangerous team in the league. Detroit gets love. They keep one eye on the Tigers and another on Houston, with the discussion settling into the idea that the Astros are playing serious ball even if they are not fully whole. The All-Star break matters. Trade chatter hangs over the baseball segment, because the hosts keep saying the real answers will not come until the break passes and teams show their hands. The NHL barely registers. That shrug is part of the episode's shape, because the conversation is much more interested in summer baseball momentum than in pretending every sport needs equal airtime. Texas closes the loop. A heat joke about an Instagram cookie shaped like Texas leads into a final stretch about the weather and the feeling that the state is already cooking before summer is even fully underway. The ending stays playful. They sign off with the kind of messy, self-aware outro that fits the show: a little profanity, a little ribbing, a lot of familiarity, and a blunt promise that they are still thinking shit through one podcast at a time.

As heard by us

A loose sports hangout where the chemistry between the hosts does most of the work.

Critical Thinking Podcast settles into an easy sports hangout, moving from movie chatter into a long baseball stretch. The draw is the give-and-take: jokes land fast, opinions come just as quickly, and the whole thing feels like friends talking over a table rather than a…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a baseball hangout that talks like friends arguing between innings.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Critical Thinking Podcast