Crimehub: A True Crime Podcast · Crimehub Studios

The Luke Mitchell Case: From Teenager to Convicted Murderer

·59 min·4 clips

Luke was treated as the only suspect within 10 days, while his face hit Scottish front pages as "Satanist" and "wicked."

Luke Mitchell enters as a boy from Dalkeith, Midlothian, whose rebellious, alternative interests made him stand out in a small, conservative town. He was 16 when he lost his freedom. By 2008, he was 19 and still 17 years away from any real chance of parole. He had been convicted in 2005 of murdering his 14-year-old girlfriend, Jodie Jones, and he has always said he was innocent. The episode sets the case against the small-town backdrop and the social suspicion that gathered around him early. Luke was at home when Jodie was murdered. He also led the search party that found her body. That should have made the investigation more complicated. Instead, within just 10 days, police had made him not only their prime suspect, but their only suspect. The story shows how quickly public judgment followed police judgment. The schoolboy was effectively convicted in the court of public opinion before trial ever began. The episode then moves into the trial itself, which was the longest in Scottish history for a single accused. A jury of eight women and seven men returned a guilty verdict in 2005. From there, the narrative follows Luke’s long effort to challenge the ruling. He filed his first appeal in 2006. The case dragged on for years. The episode also lingers on the material police used against him. Officers searched his home and confiscated belongings that were treated as incriminating. His schoolbooks were photographed and released to the press. Their satanic inscriptions were presented as evidence of something darker. A limited-edition Marilyn Manson album was taken as well, along with imagery from a surreal film and artwork tied in investigators’ minds to the brutality of the killing. The program keeps enough distance to show how thin some of those links look when laid out plainly. It also notes the pathologist’s account of Jodie’s injuries, including extreme mutilation, deep knife wounds, and facial disfigurement. The brutality of the crime is never softened. The episode then returns to the long afterlife of the conviction. Luke applied for parole and was denied the very same day. The board said it could not adequately assess the risk he posed, and the episode suggests a psychiatric evaluation classifying him as a sexual risk to women may have weighed heavily on that decision. In January 2025, he was finally granted permission to challenge the ruling. On February 6, Edinburgh’s Court of Session reviewed the legality of the denial and upheld it that same day. The case remains active. So does the argument over whether Luke Mitchell is a murderer or a man still fighting the verdict that shaped his life.

As heard by us

A grim case study in how quickly suspicion hardened around a rebellious teenager.

The episode follows Luke Mitchell from a rebellious teenager in Dalkeith to a life sentence for Jodie Jones's murder, and it keeps its focus on how quickly suspicion hardened around him.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a true-crime case where doubt lands after the verdict, not before it, and keeps hanging there.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Crimehub: A True Crime Podcast