Crimehub: A True Crime Podcast · Crimehub Studios

The Genesee River Killer | Arthur Shawcross

·56 min·1 clip

It begins with a child running home from the river with worms, a fishing rod, and a new friend to talk about. That friend is Arthur Shawcross. Mary Blake hears the story and, almost immediately, understands what her son cannot. She tells him not to go near the man again. The episode uses that warning as a hinge, letting the listener feel how danger can sit right inside an ordinary kitchen. Arthur is introduced as a tall, slim Vietnam veteran with muscular arms and sloped shoulders, a man able to blend into local life. Children trust him. Adults are slower to see what Mary sees. The story moves forward through his crimes and the geography that held them. It follows his first killings, his imprisonment, and the later failure of distance to keep him from harm. He is eventually found boarding in Rochester, far from the people who knew what he had done. He finds a new girlfriend, takes a small home on Alexander Street, and keeps moving through the city. Then the murders begin again. Dorothy Blackburn, called Dottie, is presented as a woman trying to survive addiction, money trouble, and the men around her. She disappears after being sent out to work. Her family searches in fits and starts, and the police do not find her immediately. The episode reconstructs the discovery of her body in a Genesee River culvert with cold precision. The image is ugly and hard to shake. From there the narrative widens back out to Shawcross himself, his prison notoriety, and the grotesque stories he told about cannibalism and appetite. It does not treat those claims as myth to admire. It treats them as part of the performance he built around himself. The ending brings the timeline to his death in 2008. It leaves the listener with the blunt fact that he is gone, but only after showing how many people had to live with him first. The episode is less interested in sensational flourish than in the ugly continuity of his violence. It is a portrait of predation, failure, and the long shadow of a man who kept being allowed back into the world.

As heard by us

A hard, methodical account of how a local man became a killer.

The episode follows Arthur Shawcross from a local figure trusted by children to the Genesee River Killer, opening on a boy fishing and widening into murder, parole, and the failures that kept bringing him back into view.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A friendly neighbor story turns into a serial-killer warning.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Crimehub: A True Crime Podcast