Crime Show Investigations · Zero Ideas Company

Criminal Minds S1E10 “The Popular Kids”

·1 hr 22 min·5 clips

Hotch says there has never been a proven human sacrifice in satanic ritual killings.

1. Crime Show Investigations covers Criminal Minds season 1, episode 10, "Popular Kids," around a case in McAllister, Virginia, where Adam and Cherish are attacked in the woods. 2. Mari hosts with Leah and Violet, and all three discuss the episode as a watch-and-commentary recap that reacts to specific scenes and character beats. 3. The episode asks whether a Satanic symbol, two dead bodies, and a missing cheerleader point to a real cult or a local killer using ritual imagery. 4. The opening shows Adam and Cherish running in the forest, with Adam calling Cherish "just a cheerleader" before the attack begins. 5. The sheriff recognizes Adam as a football player, and the team notes that the first body was found with a skeleton 75 feet away and nearly identical head wounds. 6. JJ brings the case to the round table room, where the photo marked "SATAN LIVES" and the upside-down pentagram push the team toward a public-relations problem as well as a homicide. 7. Reed explains the 1980s "satanic panic," the book about repressed memories, and the bureau's conclusion that many ritual stories were urban legends. 8. At the crime scene, Reed finds hardened wax and suggests candle wax, then links candles to rituals and birthday cakes while the sheriff asks, "what kind of doctor are you?" 9. The team learns that Adam was the local football star, the area is hard to navigate, and any offender moving through the mountains would likely need to know the terrain. 10. JJ convinces Sheriff Bridges to call for local volunteers so the team can profile who shows up, and the search begins with Reverend Paul organizing the grid system. 11. Garcia later reports that the town is filled with upper middle class families, Reverend Paul was arrested for embezzlement two years earlier, and Henry Dent has debt and an assault record. 12. Elle gets paired with Henry Dent during the search, and Henry later turns up with a note that says "sainted commands the virgin to be sacrificed at the next full moon." 13. Hotch tells the team that there has never been a proven human sacrifice in satanic ritual killings, though cult murders like Jim Jones and the Manson family are real. 14. Hotch's profile points to a charismatic local man, someone older than the teens, memorable enough that outsiders would see him as strange and scary. 15. The profile also suggests younger male followers, heavy metal music, sex, drugs, alcohol, and a leader who blends into the area because he is from there. 16. The team then traces the lead to Mike Sasso, a man in his late 20s who hangs out with high school kids, calls them the "Lords of Destruction," and talks about being "the one true god." 17. The episode alternates between procedural investigation, town-gathering scenes, and long stretches of character commentary from the hosts reacting to Reed, JJ, and Elle. 18. The tone is conversational and reactive, with Mari, Leah, and Violet pausing to joke about labels, coffee, small towns, and biblical names while still tracking the case details. 19. Listeners who like Criminal Minds breakdowns, profiling, and small-town case analysis will get the most from this episode. 20. Listeners who want a tightly edited recap with no side conversations may skip it.

As heard by us

A warm, wandering recap that keeps a Criminal Minds case grounded in character and banter.

Crime Show Investigations follows a Criminal Minds case built around Adam's death, Cherish's disappearance, and a nervous local reverend, with the recap moving steadily from Reed's awkward arrival at the police station to the football-team clues and the area's old murder-suicide…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For a chatty Criminal Minds recap with baby-deer Reed energy and plenty of friend banter.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Crime Show Investigations