MISSING: Bonnie Lee Schultz Part 2

January 19, 2026·59 min·5 clips

Police never searched Rick's house for years, missing key evidence in Bonnie's disappearance.

The excerpt starts with ad copy. Once the case audio comes in, everything narrows to Byron's interview and the rumor that Bonnie had an affair. He asks it plainly, without much runway. The man being interviewed says he did not know about any affair, though people have asked him about it for years. Then Byron asks about remarriage, and the answer lands in a sadder place. He talks about trying a few dates, but none of it feeling right. Hope is the part that still bites. He says he is still hoping Bonnie comes back, even while admitting that probably is not how this ends. Byron keeps pushing on the emotional weight, and the response is almost too quiet. The phone call did not bring the pain back, he says, because it never left. That is where the interview changes temperature. Gretchen is out on her own, Josh is gone at work or somewhere else, and the nights are him and the dog. Suddenly the case feels small, domestic, and lonely. He says there has not been face-to-face contact with anyone outside the three of them in a long time, and he repeats that he is innocent. What keeps him moving day by day is knowing he had nothing to do with Bonnie's disappearance. The interview never resolves. He wants to know what happened, but he is scared of knowing how it happened. That uneasy middle is the whole thing: suspicion, grief, and one missing answer.

As heard by us

A restrained missing-person episode about suspicion, hope, and the damage done by ten years without answers.

Bonnie Lee Schultz's disappearance comes through here as a case trapped in the aftershock, years after the first panic should have faded. The episode centers on detective Byron pressing Bonnie's husband about the rumors that still cling to the case: whether she was having an…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Ten years later, Detective Byron asks Bonnie's husband about the affair rumors, the dates he never wanted, and the hope he still has. Your gut will have opinions.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Crime Junkie