The Truth About Coaching vs. Therapy (and What You Actually Need) with Rivka Geoghegan

June 2, 2025·42 min·4 clips

Amy introduces a deep conversation on coaching vs therapy and why leaders tie self-worth to work.

This episode features host Amy Lynn Durham and guest Rivka Gagan, an executive coach and licensed psychotherapist, clarifying the distinctions between coaching and therapeutic support. They aim to help listeners identify which service might better serve their current needs. The conversation specifically addresses founders and leaders who often link their self-worth to professional achievements. Rivka Gagan brings over two decades of experience as a clinical psychotherapist to the discussion. The hosts plan to unpack the real differences between coaching and therapy. They explore how individuals can determine which form of support is most appropriate for their situation. A central topic is why many founders and leaders tie their self-worth directly to their work output. The episode provides strategies for stopping this pattern of conflating identity with professional performance. One key insight is that understanding the boundary between coaching and therapy is crucial for seeking effective support. The conversation reveals that the choice between these services depends heavily on an individual's current psychological state and goals. A surprising claim may be that leaders frequently use coaching when deeper therapeutic work is actually needed. The episode offers validation for those confused about where to turn for personal and professional development. Memorable moments likely include Rivka explaining the clinical frameworks that differentiate therapy from coaching. The hosts provide actionable steps, like taking a "micro step" for mental well-being. Listeners are invited to assess what support would make them feel more grounded and whole. The tone is supportive, insightful, and conversational, designed to demystify a complex topic. The style is educational yet personal, blending professional expertise with relatable guidance. This episode is ideal for entrepreneurs, executives, or any professional uncertain about whether to hire a coach or therapist. Listeners seeking strategies to separate self-worth from work performance would find it valuable. Individuals looking for a purely clinical or academic dissection of psychotherapy should likely skip it. Those already with a clear, established support system may not need this introductory framework.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Create Magic At Work®